Based on 117 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
303 Denise Rd, Rochester, NY 14612
Phone: (585) 434-4766
Hours
| Tuesday | 2–8:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 2–8:45 PM |
| Thursday | 2–8:45 PM |
| Friday | 2–8:45 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Monday | 2–8:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mayme Jordan
This place is newer from what I hear, but the food was really good! We had a trash plate pizza and it was delicious!
… more
Kiley Staats
We found Pie Time about a year after moving near it. It has never disappointed. It’s closer to a NYC style pizza, the wings are nice and crispy (The way we like them) and the sandwiches and sides are good as well.
… more
Lori Q
Starting with the positive as we normally order via Grubhub. The calzones are fabulous and it comes with sauce I have never tried. Tonight we decided on the garlic knot crust pizza w pepperoni. First, tastes nothing like a garlic knot and looks nothing like the crust pictured. More importantly, the sauce is TERRIBLE and ruins the pizza. It is bitter! Like it was from a generic company. The cheese and pepperoni is sparse as well. Normally I would complain to Grubhub (only when truly warranted) but I have yet to ever see a refund. I advise Pie Time to find a different sauce…it’s beyond awful.That being said, steer clear of the pizza! I will order the calzones/ stromboli again SANS sauce!
… more
Betsy Cruz
I liked the pizza. We ordered pizza yesterday and that was good. They offer unique flavors, but I ordered a garbage plate today and it was terrible. The fries tasted like oil and weren’t seasoned. Burgers were not seasoned and kind of dry. Mac salad tasted like it was boiled too long and had no flavor. It didn’t give me any options to add ketchup or mustard. Basically stick to the pizza.
… more
Samantha Hass
I really wanted to love this place as it’s very conveniently located for me and I prefer supporting small local businesses. Unfortunately my wings were very dry and I could tell that they had been freezer burned prior to cooking. The wings were also small and not very meaty. The sauce however was good.
… more
Aaron Buffa
The owner Joe is amazing his pizza is not just the best in the 585 but his pizza is just that absolutely phenomenal
… more
Josh Smith
We tried Pie Time for the first time last evening. Our order was made correctly, and the gentleman working was very nice. But unfortunately, we didn’t care for the food. The pizza was so thin that when you picked it up it flopped
… more
Malaya Cristine
Great pizza and wings. It was a little pricey but with everything going up these days it’s understandable. Great customer service and products!!! Familiarity is key!!! They are pretty consistent!
… more
Alexander Hillis
I’m a big fan of the $10 large pizza pickup special here…they don’t advertise it, but it’s the best deal in the area, and the pizza is quite good
… more
Rich Seeger
Really nice pizza. Good flavor on the crust and not nearly as greasy as any other local place I’ve had. Also seems to be the only place I know of that actually makes your wings crispy when your order then crispy. Definitely recommend.
… more
… View more