Based on 138 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
10914 S County Line Rd, Zanesville, IN 46799
Phone: (260) 638-4147
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 4–7 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Melissa W
Y’all this is the best pizza I have had in Indiana. Just a quick background on my love for pizza. I grew up in New Haven CT and anyone who know anything about pizza knows New Haven CT has the best pizza. Well I have lived in Indiana since 2011 and have not found pizza worth buying a second time until now. Not just a second time will we be buying but we have ordered more to bring home tonight.
… more
Dee Messman
After the place was sold, the pizza wasn’t any good. New owners changed the sauce and crust, taste like cardboard. The subs are awful! We stopped ordering from there. We miss the old owners and their pizza recipes.
… more
Jake Hamilton
The best pizza I have had in Indiana and it’s a small mom and pop place They make you feel like you’re family even it being our first time eating there great people owner Dan was very friendly and Tiffany the bartender/waitress was on top of everything It was a great experience and will be going back many many more times Thanks for finally bringing great pizza to Indiana
… more
Janelle Hartman
Food was great! I had the vegetarian pizza and my husband had the Italian sub. We were both very very pleased. The cheesy bread was delicious as well. We were in a big party and some food was missed being cooked but they corrected it and it was handled very professionally. We will definitely be back to try more of their food!
… more
Amy Lothamer
Friendly environment, good food and great service! I like how the owners engage with their customers.
… more
Jeremy Shoemaker
I thought the pizza was great! The atmosphere is good too. It really makes you feel like you’re at home. It is an old unassuming country store that happens to make awesome pizza. Well worth the drive!
… more
Raymie Bywater
WAY TOO EXPENSIVE FOR WHAT YOU GET Also they don’t have subs, which is on the Menu. Never Again
… more
Rhonda Eastom
This is a family favorite! When my kids and grandkids visit, they usually want pizza from County Line! The pizza is my favorite – not greasy, quality toppings, and generous amounts of all of it! The service is excellent, and I always feel like like my business is appreciated.
… more
Tamra Adams
Didn’t know that we could write a review! Would have months ago! Let me tell you. You wont find pizza this delicious anywhere! Since Alice and Mark took over it’s the best pizza that my hubby and myself love. Also the ham and cheese sandwich is a favorite of my hubby and my dad. My son loves the chicken club sandwich! Lots of toppings and cheese! The crust is perfect and the price is fantastic! I cant say enough! Just have to try it! Alice and mark are great people!
… more
Anthony Casey
Solid experience. I ordered a 12 inch pepperoni. I really liked the sauce. Nice balance of savory/sweet without being too acidic. The crust was on the thin side which I like. There was also substance to the crust. A little bit crispy with some chew. If I was passing through Zanesvillle, IN again, I wouldn’t think twice about eating there again.
… more
… View more