Formal landmark that once hosted Theodore Roosevelt, offering steaks, brunch & a buzzing bar scene. Based on 971 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, NY 11732
Phone: (516) 922-2500
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 5–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–10 PM |
| Thursday | 5–10 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 5–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
David S
The Sunday Buffet was magnificent! Like being at the Winn Hotel in Las Vegas, it was that good and even better because of the fresh lobsters!
… more
Brad Ev
Ok, this is the third consecutive year that my wife and daughters took me to Rothmann’s Steakhouse for Fathers’ day. I always have the same experience, FANTASTIC!
… more
WARDROBE CREATOR KEN
New to the area was in town just for one day to help a client with his wardrobe. Decided to pop into Rothmann’s; great experience.
… more
Lee Gee
Neither of us had been to Rothmans steakhouse in a while so we decided to give it a try again. The valet parking was convenient first pulling up. We had reservations and we were a few minutes late but we were seated immediately. The place was packed. The seats and tables are very close to each other and it was very loud. Eventually you adjust to the noise but it makes it a bit hard to hear. We ordered the burrata mozzarella appetizer which was very good. I ordered the filet mignon cooked “Pittsburgh” (black and blue) but it came cooked medium well instead. I had to send it back as I can’t eat meat overcooked. My friend ordered the bone in rib eye medium but came medium rare. The flavor was good. We also ordered 2 sides which were creamed spinach and mashed sweet potatos with pecans, both of which were good. The manager was very friendly and came by to check on us quite a few times, and when he realized the issues we had with our steaks being cooked incorrectly he was kind enough to comp our desserts! We had the creme brulee which is a classic and was good. We also had the apple tart with vanilla ice cream which was good also. After our dinner we had a drink at the bar which is very pretty and the bartenders were very nice. All in all it was a nice night ✨️
… more
Thomas McDermott
What a great upscale steakhouse. The atmosphere is very classy (e.g., valet service, beautiful architecture, trendy bar area, classy restaurant seating and properly dressed wait staff). There are a ton of drink options including wine and spirits with detailed menus separate from the food. Dinner menu is typical of a steakhouse with the addition of sushi.
… more
Sandy
Thought the food was ok. Had higher expectations given the reviews, the pictures, and the value but was slightly disappointed.
… more
Dan Schwartz
Went here for an office holiday party. Overall, the food was very good. I will say the wait staff was rather aloof and very easily disturbed. If you asked for something, you got a rather rude response. This happened when we wanted more pre fix menues as only one was offered for the entire table. We also got some attitude when one member of our group wanted a larger glass for soda and was refused, but got two small soda glasses instead. Later he was refused an additional drink. This kind of service was not expected given the prices charged and the reputation of this place. For this reason, I would not recommend this for a larger group. The food was good. It was the service attitude left a lot to be desired at our two tables.
… more
Richard Raschke
The lamb was not served to the doneness requested. The waiter tried to convince us it was. Eventually was cooked a little more and re-served. It was better but not ideal. At the conclusion of the meal we were given the leftovers of both meals in a to-go bag.
… more
Fish Fellas
I haven’t been here for brunch in a while since before Covid. I have to tell you it’s better than it was before! Best brunch buffet very upscale very organized very safe. Absolutely everything and anything you could want for breakfast or lunch or you can eat bottomless coffee and a complementary drink included with the brunch the service was incredible even the servers making the omelettes and waffles were accommodating. I can’t recommend this enough I took my fiancé for his birthday just a little while ago I felt I needed to leave this review. The price tag is a little high don’t let it scare you, you are getting far more than the money you’re paying. It won’t let me add my video but here are some pics.
… more
Chriz McVain
The best brunch spot I ever been to. Very professional staff, and very hard working staff. The food was great. The selection was phenomenal. The desserts was also very delicious. It’s worth $59.99 definitely have to go back and do it again. It’s a whole lot more thats there.
… more
… View more