The Tastes You crave, The Quality You Trust Since 1985!
Have you ever wondered why Cristy’s Pizza tastes so good?
It’s simple, if you’re going to have the best pizza, you’ve gotta start with the best ingredients, like…
Bold Sweet Sauce from Fresh, Vine-Ripened Tomatoes
Signature Dough Recipe
All-Natural Premium Cheese
Fresh Vegetables
Old World Pepperoni
And of course, a team of Pizza Pros to make the best pizza every single time.
Unassuming eatery for pies, salads & subs, plus beer, wine, cocktails & a small outdoor patio. Based on 635 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1436 Tiki Ln, Lancaster, OH 43130
Phone: (740) 687-0770
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
shawna Bell
Ordered my food ahead, and then couldn’t get there on time because I was stuck waiting at the vet office. Didn’t get there until an hour after my food was ready and was unsure whether they would have my food still. They did, and it was kept in the warmer. Food was nice and warm and surprisingly didn’t taste like it hadn’t just come out of the oven. The pizza bites are delicious! Very happy with the service and food after what was a stressful day at the vet.
… more
PAUL McDowell
Went to Cristys tonight after seeing taco pizza billboards dor the past week. The place was dead our waitress started off nice we told her we wanted the taco pizza and onions rings that in her words were “huge” and our our drinks, she brings us our drinks then the onion rings. After we ate the onion rings she came over and ask how they were I said they was ok and that’s when the service turned kinda sour she was like well I guess everyone’s taste are different. Imo there was a frozen onion ring. So she bring out the pizza and we take a few bites and well a taco pizza had hardly any neat on it and it tasted like they used a combination of tomato sauce and salsa for the base. Also they put the tomatoes on before they baked the pizza and warm mushy tomatoes are not very appealing. I felt the crust was to thick for a taco pizza add in warm tomatoes and no lettuce the taco pizza fell flat. She never asked what we thought of the pizza. Will we go back I doubt it. Would we recommend no.
… more
Jonathan Bukey
This is the best pizza in the area if you like flavor and a sauce that’s not just sweet tomato paste. I’ve known people who have worked at Cristy’s in the past, and they’ve been able to attest to the quality ingredients used. The subs and even salads are great as well if somebody doesn’t want pizza. The two downsides of Cristy’s are both cost. One cost is the price being higher than competition, which I feel is justified. The other cost is possibly your health as this is the greasiest pizza I’ve ever encountered. These add up to Cristy’s being a great choice on occasion.
… more
Doug Lynch
I’ve been eating cristy’s pizza for many years but the last one was quite disappointing. No harm no fowl, I ate the box instead. Reminded me of the Dominos pizza of old, and still the better value. Have the kids eat the pizza and the adults the box that tastes the same.
… more
Greg Cenn
I have never lived in Lancaster, but I have lived close and dated there. Love this place still. Went there yesterday on my way through with my daughter and just love the pizza. Pizza is good there!
… more
Jenn
First time dining here. It has a bar and booths lining the wall. We ordered deep fried pickles and Mac and cheese bits. I hadn’t ever had thr Mac and cheese bits they surprised me they were good I ordered a burger did fries don’t think I would get that again the meat didn’t taste like a burger but the fries were good my grand baby order a pizza from the kids choices it was a pretty big pizza for a kid but she said it was good my kids ordered calzones they said they were good I’d go back again but I’d order pizza sub or calzone but had a great time eating and visiting wit my kids and grandkids
… more
Lee Collett
If you need to read the review about Christy’s Pizza, you haven’t been here. If you haven’t been here, I recommend you come and give it a try. Eat in 1st, you will want take out and delivery after giving it a try on future cravings for their food. Good sauce on the pizza, the pepperoni is under the cheese. Try the zucchini sticks and pretzel balls as an appetizer while waiting on your pizza. Great family place and atmosphere. Highly recommend you give it a try. Many options on pizza toppings…
… more
When Two Became Three
Food is always the best.. price is fair and ambiance of place is clean and service was fast.. waitress was so kind and nice..
… more
Wonder Mel
Update: just got a Togo pizza from carryout. It was perfect.
… more
Josh Byrd
Pizza was all crushed and slid to the side and crushed, my cheese bread had sauce spilled all over it.
… more
… View more