Based on 86 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through
Address:
5808 Columbus Pike, Lewis Center, OH 43035
Phone: (740) 201-8864
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ben Sanborn
The BBQ here is insanely good, I’m 100% confident it’s the best in the area, by a huge radius.
… more
Grayze Dynamics
Just picked it up. She said I would love it and she was right. To put it mildly, I will definitely go again. I love Cole slaw and it was great. BBQ was excellent and I even loved the German potato salad. You’ve now got a fan for life. I’ll be back real soon. I can’t even imagine how good it is right off the smoker. Now I need to get it right off.
… more
Damon Renick
Had the brisket and pork burnt ends. Both were very good. The sauces were amazing although not needed because the flavor of the meats were delicious. The baked beans were also really good, had the German potato salad and it was a little on the sweet side and kind of mushy, but maybe that’s how it’s supposed to be idk. Indoor seating was small so hopefully they will grow out of this location into something with more and better seating. Overall a great meal and experience.
… more
DWAYNE BENEZE
Let me start by saying that I have never left a review online for anything. This is my first, but I felt that I had to for this place.
… more
Michelle Irvin-Monahan
We had Martiny’s BBQ caterer our sons graduation party and everything went off without a hiccup. Not only was the price point reasonable but the food was immaculate as always. I still have friends contacting me for the name and info of our caterers. Best BBQ in town; hands down!
… more
Tyler Cochrac
Found the good to be exactly what I wanted . We got the Mac and cheese bowls and they were delicious. Their bbq sauce is pretty fantastic.
… more
Tony Natarian
Fantastic authentic smoked BBQ. Smoke flavor and texture of the meats were spot on. This type of flavor doesn’t come from a “city” place if you get my drift. The Mac was creamy with a nice kick and the taters were nice and tangy! It’s nice to be able to take a perfect bite of a rib and although their sauces are great I enjoyed them dry because the rub and smoke added all the flavor I needed. Online ordering was easy for a quick pickup.
… more
Cristine Ditomassi
Very Good! Lovely smoky flavor, brisket was lean, and well smoked. Very good homemade sides. Definitely recommend
… more
Josh Skovira
My son and I are always on the lookout for good BBQ and Martiny’s did not disappoint. We both had the ribs and they we cooked perfectly with just the right amount of smoke. I also tried the brisket, again done to perfection. Service was good and quite helpful. Special thank you to the man who stays up all night with the smoker. Your hard work comes through on the quality of the food. We live 4 hrs away but are out here once a year. This is our new yearly tradition.
… more
Christi Friley
Very small dine in area but has carryout and drive-thru. Good brisket, pulled pork is amazing! If you like vinegar in your sauces and sides and not afraid of brown sugar, this is for you. Portions are generous, 2 people can easily split a “box”. Guy working the counter might need a little vacation or maybe he was just having a day. Worth a try! We’ll peep the chicken next time we’re in!
… more
… View more