Maxie’s Supper Club & Oyster Bar Menu – Ithaca, NY

Type : Seafood restaurant

Location : Ithaca, NY

Maxie’s is best described as a feel-good neighborhood joint inspired by the cuisine and culture of New Orleans. Super-fresh seafood and traditional dishes take a prominent menu position, and are given a serious boost by the bounty of growers and producers in our Finger Lakes region.

Maxie’s has a family friendly appeal while also being a “let-your- hair-down” and enjoy a beverage with the locals kind of place. We have great regional wines, beers, ciders, spirits, and a bartender culture to mix it up with some style and a little sass. Festive and soulful tunes, frequently live and always free from our killer local music scene, amplifies our vibe.

Maxie’s genuinely kind hospitality professionals are guaranteed to make you feel great!”

Southern dishes, shucked shellfish & live music draw boisterous crowds to this hip spot open late. Based on 847 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery

Maxie's Supper Club & Oyster Bar 14850

Address:
635 W State St, Ithaca, NY 14850

Phone: (607) 272-4136

Website: https://www.maxiesithaca.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 4–9 PM
Thursday 4–9 PM
Friday 4–9 PM
Saturday 4–9 PM
Sunday 4–9 PM

Menu

From The Kettle
Crab And Corn Chowder $5.50
Maxie’s Mighty-Mighty Gumbo
Of chicken, andouille & crawfish, served over rice
$5.95
Potato & Cheddar Bisque $4.50
Salads
Supper Club Salad
Field greens, raspberry vinaigrette, bleu cheese, toasted pecans & fresh apple
$5.95
Caesar Salad
Romaine hearts, traditional dressing, parmesan cheese & croutons
$5.95
Iceberg Wedge
With cajun ranch, double-smoked bacon, red onion & tomato
$8.95
Appetizers
Fresh-Shucked Raw Oysters
Fresh-Shucked Raw Clams
Shellfish Platter
6 oysters, 2 clams, 1/4# shrimp
Peel-N-Eat Shrimp
Served chilled
$9.50
New Orleans Bbq Shrimp
With grilled french bread
$10.95
Quarter Rack Ribs
Creamy slaw
$10.95
Cracker-Crusted Oysters
With creamy mignonette
$12.95
Maxie’s Deluxe Crabcake
With cajun mayo & “rwb” slaw
$11.95
Cajun Popcorn
Zesty fried crawfish tails with remoulade
$11.95
Fried Green Tomatoes
With remoulade
$8.50
Steamed Littleneck Clams
In garlic-butter broth with grilled french bread
$11.95
Soul-Stirrin’ Specialties
Jambalaya “Me-Oh-My-A”
Shrimp, andouille, & chicken in zesty creole rice
$18.50
Shrimp & Grits
Plump shrimp, rich & spicy tasso ham gravy, over yellow grits
$14.50
Maxie’s Deluxe Crabcake Platter
With cajun mayo, “rwb” slaw, sweet potato fries
$21.95
Jumbo Gumbo
A big bowl of maxie’s finest, served with “rwb” slaw
$14.95
Blackened Catfish Creole
With zesty tomato sauce, red beans & rice, collard greens
$17.95
Damn-Good Fish Fry
With tartar sauce, rough-cut fries, creamy slaw
$16.95
“Chicken-Fried” Chicken
With tasso ham gravy, mashed potatoes, braised collard greens
$16.95
Pulled Pork Plate
Eastern north carolina-style, creamy slaw, bbq beans
$16.50
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Topped with slaw, served with bbq beans
$12.95
Bbq Pork Spare Ribs
Creamy slaw, bbq beans
$17.95
Piggy Platter
Pulled pork, quarter rack of ribs, creamy slaw, bbq beans
$19.95
Daily Steak
With maxie’s steak sauce, bayou onions, mashed potatoes, collard greens
Cajun-Seared Ahi Tuna
With maple brown-butter, horseradish potato cake, sauteed spinach
$24.95
Vegetarian Options
Darn Tasty Tofu Fry
W/ tartar sauce, rough-cut fries, creamy slaw
$14.95
Bbq Organic Tofu Plate
W/ mashed potatoes and baby spinach
$14.95
Grilled Portobello
W/ creole tomato sauce, horseradish potato cake, baby spinach
$15.95
Vegetarian Jambalaya
Smoked tofu, pecans, spinach and red beans in zesty creole rice
$16.50
Portobello Po’boy
With cajun mayo, bayou onions, cajun fries
$11.95
Bbq Organic Tofu Po’boy
Topped with creamy slaw, served with cajun fries
$11.95
Fried Green Tomato Po’boy
W/ remoulade, served with cajun fries
$10.95
Po’boys
Bleu Cheese Burger
W/ caramelized onions, mayo
$12.95
Andouille Sausage
W/ remoulade and ‘rwb’ slaw
$12.95
Fried Fish
W/ tartar sauce
$12.50
Crab Cake
W/ cajun mayo
$14.95
Blackened Catfish
W/ tartar sauce
$14.95
Fried Shrimp
W/ remoulade
$12.95
Fried Oysters
W/ creamy mignonette
$14.95
Fries & Sides
Sweet Potato Fries
W/ chive crème fraîche
$6.95
Cajun Fries
W/ cajun mayo
$5.95
Rough-Cut Fries
W/ malt vinegar
$5.95
Bbq Beans And Rice $4.50
Vegetarian Red Beans And Rice $4.50
Yellow Grits
W/ tasso sauce
$5.50
Mashed Potatoes $4.50
Sautéed Spinach $4.95
Braised Collard Greens $4.95
Daily Vegetable
Grilled Andouille Sausage $4.95
Pulled Pork $6.95
Specialty Drinks
Maxie-Rita
Arette blanco tequila, cointreau, triple sec, sour & real lime juice
$9.00
State Street Hurricane
Dark & light rum. passionfruit and real.lime juice
$8.50
Cajun Bloody Mary
Vodka, tomato juice, horseradish & cajun seasoning, garnished with shrimp
$8.50
Oyster Shooter
Vodka, fresh-shucked oyster & cajun bloody juice
$5.00
Mojito!
Light rum with muddled limes, fresh mint, sugar and soda
$8.50
Maker’s Mint Julep
Maker’s mark bourbon with fresh mint, mint-infused simple syrup and lotsa crushed ice
$8.00
Sazerac Sazerac
Pernod coated glass with sazerac rye, peychaud’s bitters, simple syrup, served ‘up’
$10.00
Tipsy Gardener
Hangar one vodka, st. germain, fresh lemons & soda
$8.00
Skyy Citrus Cosmopolitan
Skyy citrus vodka, cointreau, fresh limes & cranberry, served ‘up’
$8.00
Supper Club Sidecar
Maker’s mark bourbon, cointreau & lemonade with a sugared rim, served up’
$10.00
Maxie Mule
Vodka, whiskey, bourbon, rum or tequila, squeeze of limes, ithaca ginger beer, on the rocks
Maxie’s Pimm’s Cup
Muddled cucumber with pimm’s, sour and ginger
$8.00
Glass Wines
Blanc De Blancs, Veuve Ambal, Nv
(Jura, fr) apricot, almond, refreshing
$7.50
Cinsault-Grenache-Syrah, La Vieille Ferme, 2016
(Ventoux, fr) tart cherry, strawberry, crisp
$7.50
Pinot Grigio, Vigneti Del Sole, 2017
(Abruzzo. It) crisp acidity, green apple, lemon
$8.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Thresher, 2017
(Central valley, chile) citrus, bell pepper, fresh
$7.00
Chardonnay “Comtesse De Marion”, Dom. Robert Vic, 2017
(Languedoc. Fr) unoaked, round, ripe pear
$8.00
Semi Dry Riesling, Lamoreaux Landing, 2016
(Seneca lake, ny) bright minerality, crisp, balanced citrus
$10.00
Montepulciano D’abruzzo Riserva, Visconti Della Rocca, 2015
(Abruzzi, italy) black currant, plum, lively tannins
$8.50
Malbec, Tinto Negro, 2016
(Mendoza. Arg) ripe plums, jammy, cocoa
$7.50
Cabernet Sauvignon, Crosby, 2016
(California) red currant & black plum, soft tannins, dry
$8.00
Cotes-Du-Rhone, Les Garrigues, 2016
(Rhone, fr) tart berries, herbs & spice, medium tannins, bright
$8.00
Non-Alcoholic Beverages
Cola $3.00
Diet Cola $3.00
Lemon-Up $3.00
Ginger Ale $3.00
Black Currant Iced Tea $3.00
Lemonade $3.50
Ithaca Soda Co. Root Beer $4.00
Ithaca Soda Co. Ginger Beer $4.00
Big Wiggle
(Lemon-up w/a cranberry float)
$3.50
Lime Rickey
(Real lime juice, simple syrup and soda)
$3.50
Roy Rogers $3.00
Tropical Storm
(Passionfruit, lime juice, grenadine)
$5.00
Hot Cocoa
(With whipped cream)
$3.00
Saratoga Sparkling Water
(28 oz)
$4.50
Shirley Temple $3.00
Draft Beer
Southern Tier 8 Days A Week Blonde Ale $4.00
Bell’s Amber Ale $4.50
Bacchus Flora’s Fate Pale Ale $4.00
Galaxy Andromeda Ipa $4.50
Good Nature Solstice Oat Stout $4.50
New York State Rotating Tap
Rotating Taps
Bottles & Cans
Utica Club
(Can)
$3.50
Pabst Blue Ribbon
(16oz can)
$3.50
Labatt Blue $4.00
Bud Light $4.00
Michelob Ultra $5.00
Sol $5.50
Abita Turbodog $6.00
Hoegaarden $6.00
Ithaca Flower Power
(Can)
$6.50
Omission Pale Ale
(Gluten free)
$6.50
Founders All Day Ipa
(Can)
$5.00
Guinness Draught
(Can)
$6.50
Dogfish Head Seaquench Sour
(Can)
$6.50
Rootstock Original Hard Cider
(Can)
$7.00
Ommegang Rare Vos $7.00
Shucker’s Choice
Miller Lite $4.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Nikoli’s Kitchen
For appetizers we had fried green tomatoes with a remoulade and the steamed clams. The fried green tomatoes were incredible, crispy and a touch spicy with a flavorful remoulade. Clams were steamed in a garlic white wine with herbs and I wish I could’ve taken a bath in that broth.

… more

Janine Odin
Great service! Delicious food. Cold beer and wine. Really nice atmosphere. We had a fantastic evening! Jambalaya was amazing! Fish and ships are the favorite of our friends.

… more

Dane Summerville
Great food, nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Excellent homemade cornbread. If you like oysters they were preparing them the entire time we were there, I mean never stopped so they must be awesome.

… more

Thomas Visicaro
Visiting the area for the weekend and I’m glad we stopped here! If you like seafood packed with tons of flavor, then this is your place! Food was delicious and the service was top notch. Be sure to make a reservation ahead of time as you will need one. Highly recommend. Great spot!

… more

marlie lukach
Great Cajun fusion food here! I really like the ahi tuna and the cornbread is also quite delightful. If you like oysters they do have a raw bar and raw bar happy hour with $2 half shell oysters. It can get pretty packed so I recommend making a reservation

… more

Allison Hutchison
I need to sing Maxie’s praises for a minute here. The entire staff deserves accolades for handling our large group with professionalism and patience. I made a reservation for 6, but then colleagues asked if they could join. I called, and the staff said they could change the reservation to 8 on the same day. Awesome. Then 2 more colleagues appeared at the restaurant while we were being seated, and the staff again accommodated us. All of our orders were perfect, everyone raved about the food (all but 2 of us were out-of-towners), and we had such a fun time. Please give our deepest thanks to your entire staff. I’m so impressed with Maxie’s every time I visit, and this time was no exception.

… more

Nina Brajdic
We stopped by after visiting the Ithaca falls and we loved it!

… more

Shelly Harmony
Amazing food! I was super impressed with everything I ate. Service was wonderful and atmosphere was great!

… more

charles lawhun
Loved the oysters on half shell. The Finger Lake Old Fashion was perfect. Smooth bourbon with excellent bitters and flavors. The Po’boy sandwiches were delicious. Fun atmosphere and great patio. Highly recommended.

… more

Kaylie Crawford
I may well have reviewed before, but Google is prompting me again and I adore Maxie’s so much I’ll give it a go again.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions