Longtime eatery offering wood-oven Italian-Mediterranean fare in a fashionable farmhouse setting. Based on 280 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
136 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937
Phone: (631) 324-3550
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 9 AM–9:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 5:30–9:45 PM |
| Thursday | 5:30–9:45 PM |
| Friday | 5:30–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5:30–10 PM |
| Sunday | 5:30–9:45 PM |
| Monday | 5:30–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Reviews
Gerard
It sounds expensive, looks exclusive and maybe “oh so fancy” but it’s not. Instead it’s a warm, inviting atmosphere with a friendly, unpretentious staff. I went in jeans and didn’t feel out of place. Give this landmark a try just once, and you’ll be a loyal regular too. PS: the background music is wonderful too!
… more
Latisha Dutch
A quite lively environment! My experience was ruined by the location of my table. My chair/back was up against the hostess stand, and I was either having to get up to let the staff pass or keep getting bumped against the table as they squeezed pass.
… more
Vikas
Eduardo is very helpful, was a bit behind their reservations but they did their best to get us seated and drinks in hand. Food was very very good, enjoyed it! The pork chop was a bit over cooked but excellent flavor
… more
Heather Dolland Tamam
It’s been a very long time since we dined at Nick & Toni’s.
… more
Lance W
Unfortunately, the place doesn’t live up to historic standards. Hoping that they can course correct and get back to what was. The only stand out of the evening was the whole roasted fish and asparagus.
… more
Nat Hoyos-Twomey
We went to Nick & Toni’s for a double birthday dinner, the food was amazing and our waiter was great. However, we had our table for two hours and when I came to the end of our time a manger can over to us an essentially shooing is off the table. I have worked in restaurants and completely understand the pressure of bookings but we were given the dessert menu 10 minutes prior and then an employee very rude taking away our menus (maybe the owner) is not okay! We should have been given the bill, when I spoke to an employee he said ‘it’s up to the server to move you along’ our server was the best! We had a great meal until the end and due to our experience but unfortunately we will not be returning.
… more
ROSARIO S. C (Batman)
The food, service and atmosphere are top notch. Our appetizers entrée, and sides were incredible!! The warm sourdough bread w/ olives and oil is the perfect start to dining.
… more
Taylor Vignali
I heard this place was played out and passed its prime. NOT TRUE! I’ve been in the Hamptons a week and this was by far one of the best meals I had. The bartenders are top notch. The food is exceptional and the ambience is insanely personal. They are an institution. They deserve major props for their commitment to excellence.
… more
RUSSEL BASDEOSINGH
I recently dined at Nick & Toni’s and unfortunately, I must leave a 1-star review for my experience. While the food was undoubtedly excellent, and the service overall was satisfactory, one incident left a lasting negative impression.
… more
Christopher Curiale
Food was good. Service was good. Management was terrible. We were rushed out of our table after a decent dinner. Blonde manager was ripping menus from our hands, making comments about our group and rushing us to leave. Very unprofessional and uncomfortable. Will not come back. Big let down.
… more
… View more