Casual roadside stop for specialty pizzas & Italian standards with tables on a landscaped patio. Based on 530 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1923 Rte 9W, Lake Katrine, NY 12449
Phone: (845) 382-2211
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Clinicalbill
Stopped in because I heard new owners/management and they have been getting good reviews on Ulster Eateries Unfiltered. Ordered garlic knots, large pepperoni pizza with extra pepperoni and additional cupped pepperonis on one half ( yeah, we like pepperoni, I guess) and a small chicken, bacon ranch pie. Garlic knots were nothing impressive, a little garlic salt on top, no infused oil and a few small pieces of fresh garlic scattered under some of the knots, had hoped that garlic was wrapped inside but sadly not, basically pizza dough. Pepperoni was good and the chicken, bacon ranch was lacking much flavour, not sure how’s that possible with bacon and ranch but it was lacking. The crust was decent under the pie but inedible at the end crush but the raccoons and skunks in our back yard scarfed it done. Seems to be the case with most pizza in the area lately with very few exceptions, food was mediocre at best, staff was friendly and fast but we will not be back.
… more
Honest Opinion
Well made THIN CRUST pizza with seemingly fresh quality ingredients. Nice place to hang out for lunch. Low key, friendly staff and an old school vibe that makes one think it’s probably been in business for ages.
… more
Dane Mowris
Terrible experience. Ordered food from here and everything was cold or missing. Ordered 2 pizzas (Only got 1) and wings and a sub. Everything was cold. And the one pizza didn’t even receive. Has to call about it and they delivered it an hour later. Which was also cold and wasn’t the right pizza. Ordered a “Cheese steak pizza” which on their app and website is described as having “Mushrooms, peppers and onions” on it. When receives none of it was on there. Called and asked about it and was told “we didn’t select those toppings”. That’s literally the pizza. When asked for a refund and would bring everything back I was told no. Would NOT recommend. If you’re in Saugerties area as I am I would recommend Brickyard pizza. I’ve had them and never had an order messed up. And much cheaper as well. Won’t be returning.
… more
Eli Brown
What a pleasure to be in a kind environment, delicious foods, and very generous portions!
… more
pat smith
Thank you for delivering to a hungry truck driver when the Burger King closed early over on the thruway. The pizza was perfect.
… more
Smarter Life
Angelo’s Pizza is a very good and dependable pizzeria. The men and women who work inside were very knowledgeable and professional. This place is very clean and has a nice flow so ordering isn’t bottle necked with seating. The pizza is amazing! You should also try their mac and cheese bites, french fries and wraps.
… more
Daisha Vazquez
As we walked in none of the workers even greeted us, we sat down , we struggled to find the menu while they all just stood there. From the start the customer service for me set me off. We went up to the front and ordered our food and asked for a pitcher of water, the cups were dirty , the water had things flooding in it. I complained so they brought another pitcher of water and once again it was filthy with things flooding in it. The sub had hair in it, the pasta sauce was very water down and tasteless, the pizza was bland , on top of that when I requested a refund they had 3 boxes ready for delivery just opened , with flies just going on the pies. This place really needs to get it together. I hate to give a bad review but this was a bit much. They need to work on sanitation and customer service, the only good thing I can say is that the manager was very professional and apologetic
… more
Rachael Snyder
The food was great. I went in to grab a slice and a salad for dinner. The guy behind the counter was so nice and the prices were reasonable.
… more
Vlogs4You
Penne Al vodka was not worth the 17$. Wasn’t expecting my favorite pasta to taste SOO different. Didn’t have much flavor. The chicken tasted like it was already cooked; and thrown into the microwave to heat it. Definitely wasn’t crispy chicken.
… more
Kristina Garcia
Great food at a very reasonable price. They are very professional and kind. I order from them on Slice and whoever delivers from their shop actually rings the doorbell, calls, and always says THANK YOU for leaving a tip. I’ve never had a delivery driver in this area thank me for a tip before and I think that courtesy and appreciation goes a very long way. (:
… more
… View more