Legendary New American restaurant in an elegant 19th-century tavern with a mahogany bar. Based on 249 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
30 Plank Rd, Newburgh, NY 12550
Phone: (845) 562-5031
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Margaret Sanchez
Perfect for us place!!! Charming and unique. A Newburgh gem with a long history. Excellent food and very accommodating owners! Im a diabetic and I asked if they had diet tonic for a gin and tonic. Owner went to the market abd picked up diet tonic for me!
… more
JoAnn Norris
Love this restaurant, established in 1801 with a lot of history. Once a speak easy, display of old jugs found on site. Intricately carved wood bar from the 1700’s. I was there for a special event dinner. Food and service was amazing.
… more
Jennifer Kosanovich
Historic location with wonderful food and service. The menu could use an update, the same dishes have been on it for years, but the chef specials never disappoint, and the braised short ribs are comfort food for sure.
… more
Michelle Miller
My partner eagerly ordered the black walnut brisket from the menu, but got a plate with white meat and tons of fat — which turned out to be the pork shoulder instead (a meat that my partner actively avoids). Taking the matter up with both the waiter and the manager, they assured us it would be removed from the bill. However, upon receiving the check, the charge persisted — instead, we received a $2 discount due to the price difference between the brisket ($30) and the pork ($28). Very disappointing.
… more
Donna Bajek
Incredible! We made a dinner stop here on our way to Maine. I have been in restaurant for many years so I can be more critical than the average gal. The jalapeño margaritas were great! Wine selection on par. They had a smoked brisket with fried onions, mashed sweet potatoes and spinach that I will crave for a long time! My husband had the short rib that you could cut with your fork and delicious! We go to Maine several times a year and we will work our schedule to be able to have a meal at North Plank Road Tavern! A big thanks to the owner for his commitment to excellent food!
… more
Olivia R
A small group celebrated our friend getting married here and they went above and beyond to ensure all had a good experience, especially the bride! The food was rich and delicious, the drinks great. Service even better. Will be back!!
… more
Terre Form
I did not get what I ordered. They refused to change the bill and/or replace my meal. Terrible experience. Not worth the money. I’m very polite and didn’t wish to make a big fuss. Yet, I feel compelled to express my dissatisfaction here.
… more
Danny Donovan
First time at the North Plank Road Tavern but not the last! Historic old building in which you can feel the history from the moment you walk in through the narrow doors and hallway. Small but very nice bar in one room with a larger dining area. The staff is very attentive and the food presentation matches the taste. North Plank also has a number of signature cocktails and house made desserts. Parking lot is located in the rear of the building.
… more
Sandra Warner
The food at the tavern was AMAZING! The flavors were phenomenal! The wait staff was very attentive and friendly. Highly recommend!
… more
Robert Jones
The staff were extremely kind and attentive. Food was absolutely flawless in every aspect I enjoyed everything ordered. The filet mignon was cooked medium well exactly as ordered and the playing was gorgeous. I honestly wish I would have remembered to snap some pictures of the meals everyone ordered but I was far too busy enjoying it. The deserts were stunningly displayed and very delicious those I did manage to snap a few pics of because everyone was shocked by how nice the presentation was. It was the best eating experience I’ve had so far in our area. I will be returning to try more of the menu.
… more
… View more