Casual, long-standing joint serving thin- & thick-crust pies & pizza rolls plus Italian entrees. Based on 630 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
401 Virginia Ave N, Tifton, GA 31794
Phone: (229) 382-4181
Website: http://www.chicagopizzatifton.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Elizabeth Kibby
We wanted pizza and the reviews here peaked our interest. The restaurant was very clean and had a nice atmosphere. Our server came out as soon as we sat down, made recommendations and waited while we looked over the menu. Decided on a small Pizzarolli and 16″ pepperoni and Italian sausage. Food came out looking delicious, both items hot and prepared as requested. Pizza and Pizzarolli both tasted great and the dipping sauce had good flavor. Overheard a conversation with the owner/manager with a couple employees, kudos to his professionalism. The only negative, the Italian sausage chunks are large which makes the pizza “sparce” on toppings.
… more
Al Lange
This place is 0% Italian!
… more
Renee Hansen
We’ve lived in the Tifton/Moultrie area for about 8 months and finally found our pizza joint! The wait time was longer than expected but they were VERY busy and it was worth the wait!! Call ahead for quicker service!
… more
Patrick Carey
We ordered delivery and it arrived at our campsite in less than 45 minutes. Rather than just ordering a pizza, I asked for recommendations and was very pleased with the unique presentations of cinnamon bread, garlic bread with cheese and sausage, and a pizza roll. Great service, great food, great delivery guy.
… more
Erica Atkinson
I’m a Tifton native. I never been to the place, and wanted to try it. The word, FAMILY, is in the name and apart of the motto, but my family wasn’t welcomed. When we arrived, we stood for some time waiting to be seated. The girls behind the station didn’t acknowledge us. Eventually, one of them asked if we were dining in? We said, yes! Then, she stated, “I don’t think we have room.” She didn’t further explain a possible wait time, nor stopped what she was doing to take a look around the restaurant. She continued to do whatever she was doing. So we left. To add, the atmosphere wasn’t culturally friendly or inviting, so much so the children noticed due to the stares and not seeing anyone who look like them. As we proceeded out the door, they had many questions about the experience.
… more
Dannielle Hills
Highly disappointed… heard great things thought we’d give a try wish we didn’t. Ordered a cheese breadstick took 30 mins was cold and under cooked. Had to keep asking for drink refills. Ordered our pizza at 6:45 pizza did not come out until 7:50 was not hot room temperature like it had been sitting out for awhile. Never once asked how it was if we needed anything. Made sure they dropped our check off with the pizza tho and was quick to ask how much we were tipping. We always tip even on bad service but found it highly unprofessional. Don’t think we’ll be giving it another try again.
… more
Maria Barrett
Needs to be swept between shifts. Food was good though.
… more
Aaron Frier (A-A-ron)
The pizza was great. This is the first place I’ve ever seen sell a 7in personal pizza. I left a few credits on the modernized juke box, hurry in.
… more
david marquez
I had the spaghetti I’m telling you the spaghetti in a can tasted way better than theirs did I was totally disappointed absolutely will not ever go back
… more
David Mayo
Great pizza with good service overall. It’s a pizza place so don’t expect to be perfect and polished.
… more
… View more