We are family owned business that supplies freshly prepared food and a comfortable atmosphere to folks in our community. We value the experience of our customers and continually strive to improve our expertise in hospitality and food service. In our efforts at Fat Angelo’s Pizzeria to retain and expand our customer base we continue to place a high value on our reputation…from food quality to customer service. While expanding to additional locations, we will remain a locally-owned, consistent place for our customers to find the quality meals they enjoy at reasonable prices..
Based on 119 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
136 Filbert Orient Rd, New Salem, PA 15468
Phone: (724) 246-1234
Website:
Hours
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Jacquelyn Benucci
Very awful customer service. Called and placed my order at 645pm i was told to pick up about 15 min later..so I went down and when I went to counter, there was a young boy there that was looking for my order n couldn’t find it, but to look on the counter and find the slip that it wasn’t even started yet. Then I told him we’ll let me pay now for it and when it gets done for him to just bring it out as I was waiting on a call from my work. Waited another 25 minutes and still no order, went back in and it was sitting on the back oven for probably 15 min or longer. Only a little order of hot pep cheese balls like how hard can it be.. I will definitely take my business elsewhere from here out . Awful..
… more
Kayla Shawley
Your food was NASTY! The only thing that was good was the cinnamon bites… The pizza and bread sticks was complete TRASH. NEVER ordering from here again!!
… more
Crystal Shaffer
Awesome wings! Just feel bad for the employees cause there is normally one girl by herself and as someone who runs multiple businesses, that don’t seem fair to her but she’s super nice and the food is awesome!
… more
Timothy Vernon
Great food and service. Savannah and Angel are the best. They were nice and made the food fast!
… more
Kayla Phillips
I always order from this location. But tonight I had the absolute PLEASURE of placing my order with Savanna. ( I know because I asked her name) She was pleasant & courteous & all around, just had great customer service! I had a terrible day & literally the 5 minutes on the phone with this woman, just ordering my dinner brightened my day a bit. I hope this review gets read by the right people because this girl deserves a raise, at the very least she deserves to be told she’s doing a good job.
… more
JILL BEATRICE
Horrible!!! Spent almost 70.00 and were rude, said they don’t deliver 3 miles away (placed order online).. daughter went to pick it up and we talked to the employees a few times.. they said the owner only issues FULL refunds or nothing!! So bottom line is my daughter had to dri e to pick it up at 7:45 so we ended up paying delivery fee and 20% tip and to top it off our Calpine, pizza and chicken tender were unedibl!! There had to be 10 cloves of garlic on the calzone was disgusting.. we had to throw it away!! I hope the 20% tip and 3.
… more
Paul Tomecek
Great food and reasonable prices.
… more
danielle barnett
Pizza and hoagies are really good, as well as very reasonably priced
… more
Isaiah
Just ordered a calzone from there, the dough was raw, and it had about a half pound of ricotta cheese in it. I hate ricotta and if I knew there was any in there, I would have never ordered it. Don’t waste your time ordering from here, you will be disappointed
… more
Ira Seaton
This review is for the Cardale location. Terrible delivery service! Ordered pizza at 9:05 on a Friday didn’t show up until 11:05! I gave up on them showing up and was brushing my teeth getting ready to go to bed when the driver showed up with my cold pizza I could tell it was made awhile ago and had been sitting on the oven trying to keep it warm. I will never get pizza here again I’ll drive to town and pick up some Papa John’s next time much better pizza!
… more
… View more
