Based on 272 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
w8326 County Rd MM, Hortonville, WI 54944
Phone: (920) 779-9701
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Derick Owens
We were led to this place because of a 3hr wait at the “other” supper club down the road…I can 100% confirm that this place is equal if not better! We walked in and waited no more than 15 mins before being seated on a SATURDAY!!! The prime rib is amazing! Flavorful and adding a lobster tail was the cherry on top! We will be back! Amazing staff!!!
… more
Freddy James
Fine dining experience, everything delicious nice soup and salad bar, seafood platter has everything you need and more, the tenderloin and shrimp combo was very good and comes with au gus really good, the service was excellent! Short staff but she kept up with every table, very proud of her efforts! Check out this place pretty sure you will add this to your dining list
… more
Lorri Reeck
The food was delicious and the service was excellent. I will be telling friends about the place.
… more
Matt Danish
Excellent service, great prices, good drinks! Go on a Friday night for the fish or a Tuesday for a steak. No matter what day you go you will experience some great food and a quiet atmosphere! When the backyard bar is open feel free to enjoy a few drinks and on many occasions live entertainment! The bartender will happily make you some of the best drinks you can get at a supper club!
… more
Jason Cousineau
Black Otter was absolutely packed at 415 so we stumbled upon MJ’s and gave them a shot. Atmosphere was friendly, much quieter than Otter. Didn’t have to fight to get to the bar Prime rib had an interesting flavor, couldn’t put our finger on it but definitely not a standard prime rib rub. A little sweet almost, just not our style. Ribeye was flavorless except one area that was heavily salted. Tenderloin filet was absolutely delicious. Ribs were excellent as well. Garlic mashed potatoes were flavorful but very dry. Potato cakes were excellent. No drink service at table and that was fine but hard to get water glass refilled also. All in all it was still a good experience.
… more
Ebony Young
Waitress didn’t come around too often. We ordered a salad bar (me) and a steak dinner (husband) medium rare which was actually well done. Added mushrooms and onions that they charged $7 for and the mushrooms were canned. Then the bill was $65.
… more
Ruth Hernandez
We showed up with 10 people and they had no issues accommodating our needs! Great food and very friendly staff!
… more
Bonnie Beschta
We found this place acouple of months ago and it’s great! Bartenders are friendly, waitresses are super, food is great and we really like the salad bar. My husband loves the seafood chowder. You really have to try this place!
… more
Dan
Staff was super friendly, there was something off with my old-fashions I just couldn’t place. Broke from my standard of always trying a ribeye my first time at a new place and tried the stuffed shrimp, excellent! Satisfactory salad bar. This spot is small so come early and get on the list. I will be back to give the ribeye a try!
… more
Keeley Kaphingst
Great dinner date with the hubs here tonight. We waited quite a while to be seated but we weren’t in a rush and the food was great! We will come back again.
… more
… View more