The Jay Street Cafe Menu – Katonah, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Katonah, NY

Based on 100 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

The Jay Street Cafe 10536

Address:
63 Katonah Ave, Katonah, NY 10536

Phone: (914) 488-9700

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 8 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 8 AM–8 PM
Thursday 8 AM–8 PM
Friday 8 AM–8 PM
Saturday 8 AM–8 PM
Sunday 8 AM–8 PM
Monday Closed

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Johan Steiner
Don’t let the name of this place fool you, as it’s a legitimate restaurant. We came in the afternoon right as they were about to switch from their brunch to dinner menu. The interior has a very chic vibe to – high ceilings, modern decor, nice light fixtures and even a dining counter. The staff was very pleasant and allowed us to squeeze in our brunch order before they changed to their dinner offerings. They have outdoor seating as well. The menu is simple and pretty straightforward and has a nice balance of variety without offering too much. My reuben sandwich was excellent. Overall, it was a very pleasant experience.

… more

kris lloyd
Staff was great and the food was good. A bit pricey but good. I’d never had cornbread French toast, interesting but not something I’d try again.

… more

Maggie Carey
Nice place conveniently located opposite the train station. Small but varied menu. Nice selection of healthy options with flair such as the passion fruit puree in the yogurt bowl! Staff was friendly and attentive.

… more

E.J. Kelley
Over the course of my life, I’ve seen no less than five iterations of a diner in this space. This one is by far the best. Awesome staff, chill vibes, and fantastic brewed beverage options of all kinds. Very much enjoyed the dirty horchata, and seeing our Brooklyn neighborhood roaster City of Saints in the homeland. Did I mention the food was great?

… more

Sari Zoe
LOVE this place! It’s my favorite local go-to place to eat!!!! Perfect lunch/brunch spot that is ALWAYS delicious no matter what you order! And consistently great every single time we go!!! And the staff are always so nice! Bonus that they are very kid friendly and always happy to accommodate my “rush order of French fries for my toddler . So happy they are now open for dinner too! Definitely recommend this place to anyone!

… more

Kim Naples
This review is for a new item on their menu- the taco salad. I was highly disappointed. It was very bland and a strange eating experience. It’s a fried tortilla topped with romaine lettuce, roasted corn, grape tomatoes, black beans, cucumber, avocado, red onion, and ranch dressing. Despite all these ingredients, it lacked flavor. I paid $19 for it. Adding chicken or shrimp was extra. For that amount I expect more. It wasn’t filling. It’s strange to me to serve a salad atop something deep fried. I’m trying to eat healthy, thus the salad. I cracked the tortilla with my fork as I ate and I added very little to the meal for taste. At least serve it with chipotle ranch for some flavor. This seems like a really poor attempt at Mexican flavor.

… more

Adrienne Summa
This place was busy, but the wonderful staff kept everything running smoothly. Cute decor inside. Lots of outdoor seating with lovely views. The service was great, and the food was fantastic!!

… more

Ja-Quan Greene
Highly impressed with the fried chicken sandwich I got. It was MASSIVE, yet remained crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. A lil messy but the wife and I agreed that it was a great choice. Side salad was ok. Could’ve used more dressing.

… more

Dan Tracy
Had the cornbread French toast (5/5) and egg sandwich (4.5/5). love this place. Great vibe, perfect brunch spot.

… more

K Lam
Overpriced Cobb salad that was doused in ranch dressing. Meh overpriced burger. Everything was just meh.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions