A large, straightforward dining room serving hearty Amish-style dishes such as roast beef & pot pie. Based on 8 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
445 Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
Phone: (614) 873-3414
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Duane Williams
We had waited at our table for 12 minutes we decided to eat the salad bar, and buffet. Love the salad delicious. The fried chicken was dry, not much flavor. The beef was very dry. The stuff peppers are very special bursting with a great deal of flavor the Green beans are tender and loaded with the flavor you expect from the Dutchman. The
… more
Maria Schifano
Had the turkey and mashed potatoes. It was tasty. Service was slow. No spoons to stir the coffee. It was like a big cafeteria inside… recommend for a very casual dinner. The gift shop was great — lots of interesting items.
… more
J Harper
Beautiful place and countryside, great drive getting there. Friendly, clean, delicious food. Bakery that included pastries, pies/cakes (home made), cheeses, james/jellies and a very nice gift shop with unique items for sale.
… more
Raymond Mulitalo
This place was recommended by a friend, and we were glad we went. It was PACKED and we waited about 45 minutes, but the bakery and gift shop helped us pass the time.
… more
Chris Hamm
I did not expect for the food to be this good!! It was fantastic!! The best salad, slaw!! Best ever!! Very fresh and amazing!! The chicken was juicy and tender homemade mashed potatoes homemade dressing monster yeast rolls….. and I could go on and on! The only thing I wished is that my wife would have been here to enjoy it with me!! She would have loved it along with all of the decorative items!! Just wish we had one closer to home!! Thank you!!
… more
Kayla Ferryman
Went here for the first time today. Love the atmosphere and the bakery ! The donuts are amazing. But they double seated us with someone, and we had to ask for refills and napkins multiple times. Also the food is mediocre, the noodles were bland but the deserts were really good just wish there was more food to choose from. But it’s good if you want desert ! Chicken was good but little dry and kept trying to get legs but they were picked over. The roast was good
… more
T W
The food is absolutely amazing. We got the buffet. It’s so fresh. The chicken is juicy! The ham has a glaze, the mashed potatoes with pasta is soo good! The stuffing is unique and those green beans are so good! There is a few desserts to choose from. Bread pudding and mystery pies. So good!
… more
D J
Had to wait 15 min before someone came to take our drink order. But other than that, food was good and waiter was friendly.
… more
Daniel Madison
Amazing food, as always. And our waitress Sherry was phenomenal. We brought friends with us from four other states & they were all raving about everything on the buffet. We’re going back next week to get another fresh peach pie.
… more
Jennie Sale
Haven’t dined here in about 5 years. We went there today for lunch party of 4. We were seated right away no wait big Variety of food that we all enjoyed. Got some delicious snacks at the bakery it was a great family gathering we all left very satisfied already planning are next trip back
… more
… View more