Pizza Star Italian Restaurant is a restaurant located in Middletown, NY. We are open for lunch and dinner and serve a full Italian menu featuring all types of Pizza, Hot and Cold Sandwiches, Antipasto, Soup, Pasta, Chicken, Veal, and Seafood Dishes. Eat in, take out or order delivery right to your door! We also serve liquor.
We also offer catering for all occasions. Reach out to us and let us know how we can help you for your next event!
Based on 131 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
400 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 381-5134
Website: https://www.pizzastarmiddletown.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J. Ford
Pizza is quality. Slice is a good size and the folks here are friendly. The dinner portions are a good size too. I always have enough food left over for a second day. The salads are good and they are filling. Food is fresh and I go back regularly. They usually throw in some bread and oh man is it soft. Very enjoyable experience. I highly suggest going here.
… more
Shadia McLean
I guess don’t order a hour before they closed. Will say the girl who took my order and ring me up seem nice. The cooks and people handling the food. No good. I ordered at 9pm even called it in. She said 5 minutes. Off rip red flag cause food need to cook. However I ordered a slice and a beef patty with cheese. When I went in the store 10 minutes later due to me ordering when I was parked outside. The guy took my food out. I left and my slice was cold and beef patty with cheese and pepperoni wasn’t even melted. The dough didn’t even cooked. If it’s a rush to closed or something like that just don’t take people order. Very distasteful. Late night getting food terrible. Have gotten food here on lunch break and great staff and food was way better.
… more
Melanie Rodriguez
Amazing pizza! My favorite is the chicken alfredo with broccoli, so so good. The food is always delicious, the staff are always really nice, and I like the old school atmosphere. My new favorite pizzeria
… more
Jen Garcia
I stumbled on this place and wish it were closer to where I lived. The Greek Salad pizza slice was honestly one of the best pizzas I’d ever had and it was so cheap. Plus the guys at the counter were super nice. We’ll come here everytime we’re in the area for sure.
… more
Mustang Mike Brewster Ford
Have had a good experience every time I’ve went. Wings good ( get the Thai chili) and the Pizza is always good. I liked the Pesto pie as well. Owner has greeted me multiple times always with a smile
… more
E
I have not been to this restaurant itself yet but they have a stand at the Orange County fair and omg the penne Al a vodka, garlic knots and meatballs that they had for $10 was so delicious and I feel like it was worth the $10 and a decent portion. Will definitely be visiting the restaurant this week to get the full meal.
… more
Joyce Lemon
1st time placing an order, received flyer in the mail. I really appreciate that they offered a small pizza and it was delicious. I will now order more often and the prices are reasonable. Good takeout service.
… more
Jackson
This Big Lots was fun! It had a lot of sporty things and snacks to get. You could get toys and scented lip balms and even body washes. I will definitely be returning.
… more
J loc
Have really good pizza with plenty of toppings many different varieties of pizza .I get pizza here quite often never disappoints always good.I got really good food and a decent price for my party platters I ordered With Raul he’s very nice and accommodating .and good owner as well….
… more
Mario Spagnuolo
Everything I had was fantastic, pizza was excellent! They were very friendly too. Definitely would like to go there again.
… more
… View more