Based on 56 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
125 Birch St E, Amery, WI 54001
Phone: (715) 268-5100
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 3–10 PM |
| Thursday | 3–10 PM |
| Friday | 3 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 3 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 3–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Jess Hayward (Turtle)
First and definitely the last time I will ever deal with these people. I’m sick and just googled delivery. These people came up. Ordered online. Cheese pizza (very little sauce due to a health condition) blueberry pizza for my kids, wings (bbq, buffalo sauce on the side with extra blue cheese and ranch) then cheesecake for my kids. Order was accepted by the restaurant. An hour goes by. I have no information so I called to check in. Girl tells me she doesn’t know. I call back again and got hung up on. The third time was bc my pizza was delivered with extra sauce, zero sauce for the wings, and frozen cheesecake. I asked if my pizza could be remade. I got some snotty little boy telling me that the quality of my food is not his responsibility and it’s my fault bc I was out of delivery range even though the store accepted the order and performed poorly on their quality of food and customer service. Absolutely ridiculous behavior.
… more
Ariana Green
Placed an order on Mother’s day for one 12 inch cheese pizza, one 14 inch pizza fry and two dessert pizzas (one blueberry and one apple) and spent over $60 with a 20% tip. Every single pizza was burnt/black around the edges so the crust was very hard to eat. My husband and I managed alright with the tough crust but it made it very difficult for the little kids to eat and so a lot of it was wasted because they couldn’t eat more than the middle where it wasn’t so hard. What we tasted was good but we probably won’t chance coming here again for burnt pizza, especially when we spend that much money.
… more
chrisolsjrify
New owners are doing a great job. Glad to have Pizza Man back. Good pizza and Decent staff and great service.
… more
Carson Waterworth
Absolutely great service and I was greeted by a cute little Mexican boy who handed me my pizza. DEFINITELY coming back.
… more
Connor Grant
Best Pizza in Amery, WI for sure. The new owners really know what they’re doing!
… more
Thomas Manske
First time with new owners, pizza was outstanding!
… more
Alycia Anderson
Update: Upon reviewing, I was contacted to receive a full refund.
… more
Jon Berg
Food was great, staff is super friendly. New owners are doing a awesome job!
… more
Kay
The pizza’s really greasy. The bread is a tough kind of chewy, not crispy. The toppings were alright but the cheese wasn’t to my liking. The more you chew, it becomes rubbery and falls apart. It’s a hit or miss probably. Probably depends on who’s cooking too.
… more
April Wilson
Delicious Pizza and Cheese Wedge bread! I really like the consistency of their food. That is very important I know what I’m getting. And if it’s off for some reason their customer service is great and they take care of the issue. I highly recommend Pizza Man!!
… more
… View more