Italian comfort food including seafood mains are served in relaxed quarters with booth & bar seats. Based on 293 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
480 Patchogue-Holbrook Rd #23, Holbrook, NY 11741
Phone: (631) 589-7777
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jay Abra
We ordered on Uber eats on Saturday around 730 pm. We got mozzarella sticks and a Margherita pie. Initially tried to get zeppolis instead of the mozzarella sticks but they did not have any available, I guess because it was later in the evening. The food came quickly. It was very good and we will order from her again. Would recommend.
… more
Danny DoCabo
Had a very delicious meal while in town visiting family. I thoroughly enjoyed the chicken marsala meal, it was clearly a fresh, tender chicken prepared with a flavorful sauce containing delicious mushrooms. A very nicely prepared dish with generous portions. i I also enjoyed the relaxing atmosphere and friendly intuitive service. I highly recommend a visit to anyone in the area if you are looking for a freshly prepared flavor packed meal. I will definitely be back everytime I’m back in town.
… more
duck duck goose
This place has a really great selection of desserts. I highly recommend the Skyscraper cake. They gave me a free sample of rice pudding. Nice gesture. The employees are always so sweet. Excellent customer service here.
… more
Andrew Blum
Carlos has a small restaurant/bar area next to the main pizzeria. Gary’s behind the bar often and also works the tables. He’s friendly and attentive. The portions are huge, the quality consistent, everything tastes great with good pricing. Pasta Primavera and Gnocchi in Meat Sauce are our favorites.
… more
Barbara B
Amazingly delicious food! Always delivered earlier than expected, hot and fresh! My favorite is the Shrimp Parmesan. Love their sauce too. Carlo’s is my go-to place.
… more
Scott
Why all the haters? Had the pleasure of eating a few Aegean slices here, and oh boy! Just like I remember back in the good old days! Lots of fresh mozzarella, delicious oregano foward sauce, perfect foldable crust. Took me right back to my youth. Of course the price is not the same. Just look at your grocery bill, and everything else for that matter. Don’t blame Carlo’s, blame our horrible leadership in Washington. Pizza for me is a guilty pleasure that is a treat every so often, so I will definitely return to this nice place for a repeat! Cheers!
… more
gstreet blak
Do not spend your money here. Spend where you’re respected not just your money you work hard for it. Tried to charge me 14.95 for 2 slices then acted like i was the problem cause the girl couldn’t count without the register. Standing at the counter while everyone Carry on like you’re invisible. Customer service is horrible.
… more
guy 8118
The first thing you see is a TV that is -always- tuned to one of those cable “news” / 24×7 indoctrination channels, as if that is a fair or decent thing to do. I didn’t waste time objecting (though others could); I just noticed, turned, and walked right back out. Insulting half of their potential customers is NOT a sane business strategy. They should lock out those channels and show -almost anything- else (no boxing, no MMA).
… more
Mike Lotierzo
Great place,, great food,, great owner and staff,,Gary the bartender goes above and beyond to make your experience there awesome,, place is like Cheers,, everybody there knows your name and we all look out for each other,, great crowd,, keep up the amazing work you do for all of us loyal customers,,, Mike L
… more
JoAnn Mallozzi
Over charged haven’t updated menus except when you dine in and when you call to tell them there was a mistake.. no this is what it is…ride, overpriced arent nice
… more
… View more