Based on 132 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1101 Highland Ave, New Castle, PA 16105
Phone: (724) 856-8061
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 2–9 PM |
| Thursday | 2–9 PM |
| Friday | 2–9 PM |
| Saturday | 2–9 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday | 2–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 2–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joss Slagle
Scustie’s employees are very friendly. The specials and prices are great. The pizza has flavor. The crust is perfect. I would prefer more sauce but overall this is a great pizza place.
… more
Trumpet Gremlin
I’ve had two pizzas from here and they were amazing. Both times I have gotten a 10 cut cheese pizza. Their sauce is amazing and has a sweetness to it. It is also affordable. I found this place through a coupon for a 10 cut cheese pizza for $6.49. This is a great place to get pizza.
… more
Theresa Kaul
We love Scusties!! Perfect crust, sauce and good quality cheese. A review said their sauce is on the sweet side, I don’t think I agree, I don’t like sweet sauce. We always ordered the round pizzas but we ordered a sicilian in addition and WOW!! It was really good!! The crust was not too thick, not too thin, just perfect!! So grateful to have a great pizza place nearby!!
… more
Ed Z
Had a hoagie. Nothing special, but was right sized and price. no seating, kinda grimy interior, flies buzzing around, sticky floor in customer area.
… more
Cece L
Their food is amazing, portions and prices are super reasonable in comparison to other pizza places in the area. Would definitely order here again!
… more
patricia miller
Horrible not Sicilian Pizza at all. Ordered the pizza and Cheese sticks neither was ate 30$ in the trash. Pizza was gross and cold and had a stage taste to it and the cheese sticks . Don’t do it
… more
Nikki Miller
First time ordering from them tonight and the pizza was great!!! The Sicilian pizza is really good. The two pizzas were ordered was. We will def come back for other stuff to order from. Thank you!!!! Plus it’s local as well.
… more
Ran Butch75
First time was good second time around was terrible. Ordered a Sicilian pizza that wasn’t even thick, it was on the thin side. Also tasted burnt. I ordered through DoorDash so it wasn’t cheap. Will not order there again. I hate wasting money especially during these times.
… more
Wendy Rice
Just caught on to this place…GREAT PIZZA!!! I ordered the Meat Pizza & added Banana Peppers. Made it that much better! Tried other things on the menu, (Calzone, I built my own, Steak Roll, etc) but nothing compared to that pizza! O…AND THEY DELIVER…QUICKLY!!! It’s my new go to spot.
… more
Robin Riglian
Ordered pizza, salad, wings and coke came with the package… coke never came.
… more
… View more