Fiorello Cafe is currently located at 730 E Gay St. Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, and more, all with the click of a button.
We offer Indoor Dining and takeout and weather permitting, we also have outside seating! We offer catering and private parties of up to 80 people!
Quaint trattoria crafting a variety of traditional Italian dishes, including brick oven pizzas. Based on 561 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
730 E Gay St, West Chester, PA 19380
Phone: (610) 430-8941
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9:45 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11:30 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: shift4payments.com
Reviews
Nelly
Fiorello cafe is a great place for families and people looking for a quick bite.
… more
Kelly Hunter
It is one of the best authentic Sicilian Italian restaurants in Chester County. I love the Fiorello’s salad, especially in the Summertime, so fresh. Also, try the Lobster Ravioli. They serve fresh baked pizza bread and salads, house or ceasar salad, comes with your entre. They have live music Ala Frank Sinatra each month, but check their schedule to be sure. The house wine us quite good, as well. I love the authentic atmosphere of this restaurant. You will, too.
… more
Rosemarie D’Ginto
Probably my favorite place for the atmosphere by far! Quaint and homey, not fancy seating which was great. I don’t like tablecloths, China so delicate I’m afraid it’ll break, and so many pieces of silverware on the table you aren’t quite sure which one to use.
… more
stacy good
This place is wonderful! The atmosphere is unique and welcoming. Our server Mama was polite and accommodating. The food was absolutely delicious! True Italian! It was fresh, full of flavor and the portions were definitely worth the money. I will certainly return!
… more
Joe Muscella
My first time here. The Atmosphere was great service was excellent and the food was amazing! The sauce was the best I’ve had in a long time. Plenty of gluten free options for me. I felt like I was home at a family dinner and reminded me of when I was a kid. The food is authentic and truly amazing!
… more
Mott U D’Potyou
Oh yeah. Five star lunch buffet! Everything fresh. Everything beautiful! Two soups, four hot entrees, pizzas and all those dishes near the oven! Exceeding expectations and probably the closest experience to Italy I can recall. Kitchen is VG. Their bread is fabulous
… more
Lena Keleshian
Had lunch today. The brick oven pizza is awesome. This is the small. Chicken Caesar salad was amazing with so much chicken I couldn’t finish it and took home leftovers. The bread they give you was so soft and fresh with the tomato pie like bread tasting great. I highly recommend if you’ve never been then you stop in. Our waitress was an older Italian woman who was an awesome waitress, so pleasant and I didn’t even have to ask for anything she knew what we needed and made sure we had water, bread, to go boxes and a bag.
… more
Irene Williams
Just returned from dinner with a friend. The food was delicious and service was okay. When it was time for the check the server refused to give separate checks. She read what each of us ordered and what we owed but did not show us the check. Then she asked for cash. Did not want us to use a credit card. After we paid she came back to the table because she said my friend did not tip her. My friend did leave a tip. Will never go there again and will share my experience with everyone I know.
… more
Maryjane Goetschius
When we walked in, the man in charge was abrasive and made us feel unwelcome. He put us at a table between two big parties which was so uncomfortable. We asked to be moved outside. He acted like we were a bother. Unfortunately the food was also terrible. The gravy was a crazy weird color and had no flavor or spices. We ordered a mushroom dish that obviously used cans instead of fresh. The eggplant, although thin was under cooked. The mozzarella cheese was grainy and obviously not a good quality. The reviews on this place are so positive, I wonder if they have one menu for regulars and one for strangers. And a discrepancy is their claim they give you focaccia. It is not that but slices of pizza.
… more
Charles Valenza
Visited 4/2/23: My family and I have been loyal customers of this establishment since returning back to our hometown since 2010. This is Old World Sicilian Cuisine. The staff is friendly and very helpful. The menu is exquisite and so many options to choose from. I highly recommend the Fried Calamari which we started with, then we ordered two large wood-fired pizzas, one Quattro Gusti & a white pizza with extra garlic. Their pizza is out of this world good as we enjoyed it many many times. Our server is the mother of the owner who is a great woman and so wonderful at interacting with the customers. We also love Josephine who is the kind woman behind the bar, she’s part of the family as well. As a Sicilian family ourselves we are always warmly welcomed! Definitely check out Fiorello Cafe! Highly Recommended! Tell them Charlie sent ya!
… more
… View more