Based on 452 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
615 E Moss Mill Rd, Absecon, NJ 08205
Phone: (609) 652-0378
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
gabby johnson
Come here for the WORST pizza you’ll EVER have. We order the buffalo pizza and the buffalo chicken Mac and cheese, both were disgustingly sweet, we could not eat either so both ended up in the trash. An absolute waste, DO NOT COME HERE. The pictures look great but the food is inedible. You’ll spend $27 for a picture and nothing more. We threw everything away and went somewhere else to eat.
… more
Judy Privetera-Parrish
Every time we order they forget something. We always call and they say they will send it and never do. Last time we ordered they forgot the wings (again) and we ordered a Stromboli but got a calzone
… more
Kurt G
Costello’s Pizza Smithville. I went in here to get 2 slices. Right away guy asks how I was paying since I was pulling out my debit. He says 10 dollar minimum so can maybe get another slice (3) or a soda. I got the extra slice total was 9.60. Wasn’t really happy about that since I get slices all over and never get told 10 min. It is not really a convenient location, at the back of the little stores so you have to park a bit away. Normally, if I get told 10 minimum anywhere I walk, but I was already there. I try to support the small business and when Corona started a lot of places were not sure if they were going to stay in business or whatnot and really wanted people to come in. I guess everybody jumping on the pandemic bandwagon now since businesses found they really did better-not worse, could charge the American people MORE and get away with it. Patriots!
… more
Queen Sam
Best pizza in Galloway. I literally just placed my order about 15 minutes ago, it’s already at my house hot , fresh and good ! One time they forgot my bag of chips with my sub, I let them know and they brought me a bag of chips with no problem.
… more
Mark Mergaerts
We had something called the Fuggeddaboudit pizza, which turned out to be a soggy pie loaded full of some third-rate cheese with a few slices of salami strewn over it, onion, mushrooms and green pepper all as good as raw, and the whole lot half-cold. Dreadful to look at and even more dreadful to eat, which we soon stopped doing. This thing is to a good pizza what crushed roadkill is to a good steak.
… more
frank Brown
Friend invited me over and had ordered pizza and “tails?”. Oh my… nothing but grease and salt. Two paper towels to blot the oil and it was still too much. My friend was embarrassed as I couldn’t eat anything. Chicken was way too salty.
… more
Geoffrey Lazarus
The pizza is great here: plain, pepperoni, white etc, whatever you get, slice or whole pie is very good. But the steak subs are where it’s at. Probably the best place in Galloway if not the county.
… more
Mikey P.
Great place for pizza by the slice.
… more
Ipaapk r
Food good but look wth
… more
Bradley Dean
Love this pizza shop. Great food, and decent prices!
… more
… View more