When you’re in the mood for good times and great cuisine, be sure to check out Medford Pastaria. The menu at Medford Pastaria features a wide array of great selections, made from only the freshest and highest quality ingredients, with something sure to please every member of your group. Medford Pastaria has established itself as one of the area’s favorite culinary destinations and is sure to offer you a pleasant and unique dining experience every time you visit. Please stop in soon!
Family-friendly eatery & pizzeria turns out pastas & slices beside an Italian street-scene mural. Based on 583 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3209 Horseblock Road, Medford, NY 11763
Phone: (631) 758-5252
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Angelz Jameson
Love this place! I love the specialty slices, I often times try new ones and have never been disappointed! The teriyaki chicken, penne ala vodka and baked ziti slices are too die for! There salad slices and pasta is really good too and their garlic knots are just
… more
C Elizabeth
we looove the personal pizzas, especially the flat crust ones with lots of tomato sauce! however, sometimes it arrives with an insane, almost illegal amount of oregano baked into the cheese. it’s so overpowering and whoever thinks that’s an acceptable ratio of oregano to pizza slice has a very questionable relationship with food/herbs. it makes the pizza taste a little earwaxy and it’s disappointing. no more oregano on the personal pizzas! we still order it, we just pray that crazy oregano guy isn’t working that day.
… more
joe logan
Medford Pastaria is great! Ordered food from them for a party. Trays were completely full and the food was delicious. Best chicken Marsala Ive had in a long time. There garlic knots are the best and everything else was excellent. The prices are very reasonable and it didn’t break the bank. Will definitely be visiting again and using for future parties.
… more
Anthony O’Brien
Pasta Special Night… Monday $21.99! The place was packed! They have a singer every other Monday. Wine or soda, choice of salad, the list of pastas and sauces are plentiful and dessert as well! Amazing…
… more
Louis Shore
We often come here for special occasions (most recently for an anniversary). The food and service here is always fantastic! I
… more
Vanessa J Herman
First time back since 2020. Service, as always, was excellent. Our dinner, unfortunately, was not as good as we remembered. Parmesan Trio with spaghetti was watered down, the pasta was not drained properly, flooded the plate and thinned out the marinara sauce. Chicken francese portion was small (two cutlets) and was incredibly bland. Ambiance is nice (when the lights are low) and staff are very nice.
… more
Elvis Jimenez
Good food great polite service clean place the bread and oil was hot fresh baked. The appetizer fried calamari was soft and crunchy, with fresh tomatoes in the sauce, i had the pasta in clams sauce and it was the best, the clams were fresh and tasty, the pasta was very good with the garlic and tomatoes outstanding presentation. The sangria was exceptional, the dessert was awesome lava cake and ice cream, i can not atop talking about the good food at this place they have a bar two fish tanks i recommend you take a drive out east and experience it for your self. From far it looks like a regular pizza shop and then your surprized
… more
CHRIS CRESPO
Great food. Ordering pizza since I moved here in Nov. 2022. Always delicious. Went in to dine Mon for first time. Food was great. Definitely recommend
… more
Genny nolasco
I don’t really write reviews but this is my first time ordering from this pizzeria. I place a doordash order for a pizza pie & a tiramisu and as you can tell in the photo that the tiramisu had fungus. The pizza was amazing but when I called the pizzeria about my order. First of all, the lady who pick up was rude and it’s not even the fact that she was rude but when I explain to her my food had FUNGUS on it she said, “ well it just came out of the oven, & I just check the other ones and they look fine” so I told her, “ do you need me to send you a photo of my food,” which she then said, “once again there all new.” And I worked in fast food for 4 years so I said “well maybe someone didn’t rotate them” & she said “well we did.” Obviously not if my food has fungus. Then hung up. Rude.
… more
Drew Birmingham
ABSOLUTELY, DISCUSSING…Dark and Danke atmosphere Prime breeding ground for cockroaches….First, served a glass of water with some sort insect swimming with the ice cubes. Then noticed a LARGE FAT cockroach scurrying from under the menu …..
… more
… View more