Based on 216 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
Address:
105 N Randolph St, Garrett, IN 46738
Phone: (260) 357-6666
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian Krus
I had to re-review since timmy bought back his business and all the delicious recipes and ingredients. Had a deluxe thin crust, damn it was good. Great to have things done the way they’re supposed to be at this local favorite. Pizza was outstanding!
… more
Shawn Payton
Excellent gourmet pizza and barbecue!!! Amazing experience Tim and staff were great! Chicago style pizza was everything we were hoping for and so much more! Wings had an amazing smoked favor and the hot was just right! Highly recommended.
… more
Libby Asher
We got a bbq pizza and a sub. The sub was decent. The bbq pizza definitely didn’t taste like it had any bbq on it but it did have a lot of meat. We got the “Chicago” style crust and I wasn’t a fan, the bottom was soggy. It was filling, but I don’t think I’ll be back.
… more
Ted Barry
We been going to Timmy’s for 7 yrs and fell in love with the Chicago style deluxe until Friday night! We never had a problem, the pizza was always delicious til friday night. We ordered a chicago style deluxe like always and got basically got a deep dish sausage. Couldnt tasteany veggies bc there was hardly any. The pizza was so salty it was hard to eat. The crust underneath was so thin and soaked with fat you couldn’t eat it like pizza. We had to use a fork. By far nowhere near the quality Timmy’s pizza we are used too. The whole pizza has changed and I think we won’t be back.
… more
Kyleigh Hart
We ordered a railroader pizza. The pizza was under cooked and the bottom was completely soggy. You couldn’t even pick it up completely to eat it. Extremely disappointed. Timmys has gone down hill, since the new management took over! Get it together guys!
… more
Kevin Park
We ordered the nachos and wings. Not good. I’ll bet the pizza is good so willing to give it another try. Nice old railroad themed decor inside.
… more
Ethan Hopper
Incredible customer service. Everybody was happy to help and they all waved me goodbye as I left with my delicious order of wings and cheesy bread.
… more
Samuel Frick
I only ate their once before they temporarily closed and remodeled their company. But I LOVED and I mean LOVED the pizza there. I was very impressed with my order.
… more
Kristina Brower (Tina Rodeman)
Was very good pizza, and what they call rolls I didn’t try, but was told they were fantastic.
… more
Haley Hand
The food is great but we NEVER get the sauce we pay for. I had higher hopes since the original owners/management returned but the streak continues. Yes, shame on us for not checking but every single time? I look forward to the sausage rolls but its not the same when you have to heat up a cup of sweet baby rays when you’re ordering from a bbq restaurant.
… more
… View more