Based on 513 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
134 W Franklin St, Horseheads, NY 14845
Phone: (607) 739-8781
Website: http://horseheadspudgies.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Misi Cady
To be perfect honest what you get for the price it just doesn’t even out! We ordered a party pack it came to 73$. The wings were dry and the pizza had barley any cheese and it was doughy! It’s a hit or miss down there I have had good food but it’s a very expensive gamble on is it gonna be good food!!!
… more
G F
Ordered dinner yesterday. Pizza and wings and it was the grosses food iv ever had. I was literally afraid of food poisoning. The wings were sickening to say the very least. I wouldn’t recommend anyone order from there. Once upon a time they were the best around but $42.42 for food to throw in the garbage is ridiculous. The board of health should shut them down before someone gets deathly ill from their garbage. Yes this is my personal opnion and thats as nice as I can say it. Be warned!!
… more
Hawaiiantrixie
Very busy pizza shop. But I can see why. Its the first time I have ever been to Pudgies. The Stromboli was packed full and delicious. Bread sticks were good. Wings were perfectly spicy and sauced. Blue cheese dressing was awesome. The canolis were honestly the best I’ve had. It was not overly sweet. Im not a big canoli fan usually, but Pudgies did a phenomenal job. Staff was friendly and personable. We ate outside at the tables they setup. With social distancing applied.. Which was excellent because you got to see the cute town of Horseheads, NY. Historical Hanover square is well kept very quaint very cute. Thank you Pudgies.
… more
james watson
The atmosphere and environment were very good. Customer service was a great plus with entertaining my son even though they had work to do. Food was definitely great and plenty for later. Would recommend eating here and trying it all.
… more
tgrp media
This place sucks. Ordered two slices and a roast beef sandwich. Not eatable, had to throw it out. Will never go back.
… more
Linda Holly
Had dinner here tonight & it was AMAZING! Ordered a medium meal deal and the cold Italian sub came EXACTLY as I ordered it with fries. It was SLAMMIN’! The subroll was SOOOOO SUPER SOFT & fresh!
… more
Charles Saunders
Nothing at all like the Southside Pudgies.
… more
Jeffrey Gilbert
Don’t go there towards night time. Went in last night and bought 4 slices and an order of breadsticks. I would have NEVER sold those to anyone. ROCK hard and OLD can’t even begin to describe it! Extremely disappointed!
… more
Neil Westervelt
Still as good as when I was a kid. Good pizza, lots of toppings. Great sauce. Friendly service. Got delivery- was supposed to take 45 mins- only took 20. It’s pretty much everything the Watkins Pudgies isnt! And I got GF crust, really good. Pricey though.
… more
Ashley Tennant
Since moving to New York, spedie sandwiches have became my favorite thing. Lol I’ve tried them all over town and Pudgies on the Southside continues to stay number one. IMO… sheet pizza is great also.
… more
… View more