Small, mostly carry-out joint, dishing up calzones, subs & New York-style pizza by the pie or slice. Based on 297 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
240 N Liberty St, Powell, OH 43065
Phone: (614) 436-8900
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tiffany Colucci
The pizza was fine. My kids loved the cheese pizza. I enjoyed the pepperoni with extra cheese. Didn’t love the Bianca (I know everyone else does lol), too much ricotta for me.
… more
James Bayes
Outstanding taste, crunchy, and everything you would think a NY slice tastes like. Walk in and buy it by the slice makes it awesome for people like me on the run. Kudos to this pizza joint, y’all make a great pizza.
… more
glasspumpkin73
Tastes like I stepped off of the Subway in Brooklyn and had a slice! This is authentic NY pizza… perfect fold, right amount of delicious cheese. I ate a slice in the parking lot, then had to pull over 3 miles later for another! Get the sausage and thank me later
… more
Jonathan Bruffy (Jon)
Always a great pie, and a great takeout option when visiting Ill Mannered Brewing Co, across the street. Pictured: margherita pizza and March 2023 menu.
… more
My Next Home Columbus – Michael Dalton, REALTOR
I love a good pizza pie but I LOVE a great pizza pie and Brooklyn PIzza is it! The “Bianca” (White Pie) to die for!!!
… more
marlene harkcom
This is the best calzone I have ever had hands down! My daughter and I have come here several times specifically to get this calzone. Their ricotta cheese is fluffy and to die for! Though this place isn’t really intended for eating in they do have two tables out front, and is nice for some people watching on a nice day!!
… more
TJ
Authentic NY style pizza. From the pizza by the slice to the can of coke, this is a must have if you’re in the area. Lunch pictured here is under $10 which is nearly impossible to find nowadays.
… more
Daniel Friedman
Growing up on the jersey shore I can say this is THE BEST PIZZA IN COLUMBUS hands down. I’m partial to NY style pizza and this place made me home sick. Traditional and delicious. Even the shop itself is similar to the pizza shops I essentially grew up in. I’m saw someone make a comment about not having pineapple- yea thanks but who cares. You want a California pizza joint then don’t come to a NY style place. LOVE everything about this place.
… more
E Smith
Fantastic pizza in Powell!! My family and I drive from Dublin to bring this back home. Some of the best pizza we’ve found since we moved to CBUS. (Pro Tip) If you have to drive a bit back home ask them half bake the pizzas and not cut them so you can finish cooking them at home. Attached pic is the Bianca. We added tomatoes and fresh cut basil to it. Soooo good.
… more
j k
Pizza was ok. It wasn’t terrible, but certainly not great. I’ve been to NYC several times and this pizza isn’t even close to NYC style pizza. I do have several other critiques as well. For starters, they do not offer pineapple as a topping, which totally blows. They also intentionally do not answer the phone to take orders if they get a little busy. While in there tonight, I heard a teen worker ask the boss if he should turn the phone back on and start answering again. That is ridiculous! Get online ordering! It is 2023! Also, they have no fountain drinks or ice available. They have cans or 2L bottles of soda with small plastic cups. The seating area is extremely small as well so I wouldn’t recommend eating there. Finally, they close at 8 pm, even on weekends! Talk about lame. What decent establishment doesn’t stay open until at least 10 pm on a weekend? Overall, I’d go elsewhere for pizza.
… more
… View more