Based on 531 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
6154 Reily Millville Rd, Oxford, OH 45056
Phone: (513) 757-4030
Hours
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11:30 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mike
We were excited to try this based on the reviews we read. When picking up our order it was rather ridiculous, yeah they were busy but I was told to wait for my food to get done and after about 10 minutes they passed it to me from where it sat the whole time I was there. The cheese sticks literally had no cheese in them, I can only assume it was all left behind in the fryer. Pizza was OK and the steak sandwiches were OK as well. We most likely would find another pizza place next time we crave pizza
… more
Justin Cotten
A fantastic place to eat, have a drink ,and listen to some music. Outdoor seating with a stunning view of the creek located just outside the back door. The pizza is worth every penny, Burt cheese out past the crisp crust, not to mention the inch thick of toppings. I will definitely be eating here again. They also have take out.
… more
Dennis W Paul jr
Best pizza in the area. Worth the scenic country drive. Great service, Good prices. Especially in today’s economy.
… more
Brooke Alexandra
Horrible. Just called twice to place an order but no answer… figured they were busy so I waited about 15 min and called back. An older man answered in a disgruntled tone “what do ya need riley pizza” and I said “hi can I place a pick up order?” He said idk can you?! And I just thought he was joking so I laughed and said you tell me! And he said I have no clue you won’t say what you want !! Shocked that someone could be so rude I just didn’t say anything and he said tel me what you want!! What’s your name!! And I hung up… rude. Never going there again.
… more
Corey
My aunt and uncle brought us here while we were on vacation. We live near Chicago and have had pizza from all over, so believe me when I say this was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We brought our leftovers home and devoured it the same evening. We will be back in the future! ❤️
… more
Chelsea T
I really wanted to love this place . This is our second time ordering out. The first time was ok but our pizza was BURNT and there was barely any sauce. We did love the steak hoagie!
… more
T. J. Hart
First pizza I think I’ve ever had that I didn’t want extra cheese on. This place is worth driving out of the way for. Great pizza with tons of cheese at a fair price. The only complaint I had was there were no fountain drinks, only cans. Decent selection of different beers for a smaller place with a handful on tap.
… more
Virginia Wilson
The sandwiches are amazing so good!!!!
… more
Heather Dutton
Where do I start. Its a dive bar. Its chaos. Its dirty. We walked in, sat at a not wiped down table for about 10 min before husband goes up to the bar to order. Asked for waters, never got them. As we were waiting for our food to cook, a man comes in with a dog. No one blinked an eye, must have been a regular. No, it was not a service dog.
… more
Sara Cullin
Reily Pizza is no frills or fuss with extra cheese. You don’t have to ask for extra cheese. I’m pretty sure they get a semi tractor load of pizza cheese each week because they use so much.
… more
… View more