Based on 72 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
Address:
91 Shoemaker St, Forty Fort, PA 18704
Phone: (570) 763-7314
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chuck Y
Tried Benny’s base on the reviews in FB. I was amazed at the number of people waiting for takeouts. Their Pizza was delicious. Wings were piping hot flavored in their Signature Smokehouse with a side of Benny’s Bacon Brown Sugar. Waitress was great but definitely needs help in a busy night. We will absolutely be returning for more.
… more
VHS
I’ve been putting off my review for a few weeks now simply because I wanted to try the pizza and it wasn’t until recent that the pizza was available. At this point I’m a little mixed about this restaurant but overall, it isn’t too bad. So far I have tried their burgers, bites, cheesesteak, and of course, pizza. The strongest of all four has to be their bites. Their flavors they have available are pretty darn tasty. The chicken can be a little dry but overall isn’t bad. Second on the list would be their pizza. The pizza isn’t too saucy and the cheese was pretty good. The crust game on the pizza however, was a little lacking. I know that probably isn’t important but to some, the crust is the best part and I thought it was a little bland. Third would be the cheesesteak. The steak on it was nice and juicy and blended with the cheese nicely. However what kills it for me is the size of it compared to the price. I feel 8 dollars is a little bit too much for what I got. Forth and last would be the burger which in all honesty, I didn’t like too much. The burger tasted almost like it might have been frozen and it was decently dry. The fries that came with it were very tasty however so at least it had a little bit of a redemption. However, being a burger lover, I was pretty disappointed.
… more
Diana Latsko
Chicken cheese steak is AMAZING and my son loves their chicken tenders. The staff is super friendly and the delivery is fast. Delivery drivers are very pleasant to work with. Fresh cut fries we very good. Reasonably priced too.
… more
Melissa Pugh
The chicken bites are amazing & the chicken wing pizza was very good! The people are very kind and friendly. I will definitely return.
… more
Eric McDermott
Great tasting boneless wings. I ordered hot garlic.
… more
Natalie Goodman
Good flavor. Very courteous and friendly staff. Did a pickup. Only criticism is they told me 1/2 hour. When I went to pick up about 20 minutes later, pizza was ready and not hot. Which means it was ready sooner. Next time I would go in about 10-15 minutes. Round pizza needs to be floppier. Will definitely get again though.
… more
Christina M
Benny’s in forty fort is my absolute favorite place. It is the only place I will get boneless wings from again. Every flavor I’ve had so far has been incredible and the amount of food you get is great. I am constantly telling people about Benny’s! Not to mention the staff has been incredibly nice every single time I’ve been there.
… more
Jewles Vega
So disappointed tonight I spent 30$ on pizza and order of wings. Pizza crust tasted like water cheese was very very different I’ll say it like that I’ve never had a pizza taste so weird. I payed for extra blue cheese didn’t get them. And I gave a tip. I’m glad I only gave a 4 dollar tip. Chicken was dryed out I wasted my money tonight I was the only customer there so I dont understand why they didn’t give me my extra blue cheese I told them 2xs. they obviously forgot but didn’t forget to take the tip lmao. I’ll find another wing spot
… more
Brian Niemkiewicz
Well thought it would be a good idea to check out this new place. Ordered something quick seeing that my buddy was in his lunch break. It was nothing short of being quick. Almost 50 min for two sandwiches. So we had no choice but to take them Togo. I’v e heard from a couple ppl their wait times are bad and this confirms it. Good food but don’t go for lunch if your in a hurry.
… more
Karen Loftus
I ordered a meetball hoagie. I could tell that they made a really good sandwich, it was a little overcooked and not very hot with very little sauce. Still, it wasn’t bad. They just opened so I completely understand. I heard great things about their food and I’ve seen pictures.i will definitely be going back. Only advise, perfect the meatball hoagie preparation. I would gladly get it again. I am
… more
… View more