The Original PJ’s Pizza is a carryout style pizza, sandwich, wing, pasta, salad shop that Ohio Valley residents have loved since 1969. At PJ’s, you can watch your order being made by their great team of employees. The shop also features Pepsi products, Mmm…Popcorn, and Mr. Bees potato chips, the only WV made potato chip. Owned by Rob & Erika Donaghy.
Based on 238 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
495 3rd St, New Martinsville, WV 26155
Phone: (304) 455-4655
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nate Greer
The worst pizza I have ever had! The cheese wasn’t melted thoroughly let alone browned and the crust was tough and chewy on the bottom and like a biscuit in the middle. I ordered an XL with 3X cheese and 3 toppings. It was almost $27 AFTER a $5 coupon for first time order online. It could POSSIBLY be DECENT at best if it was baked correctly. NEVER going back though! Stick to barristas for pizza in New Martinsville!!!
… more
Christine Tippins
I ordered takeout for the 2 days I was in town. To my surprise, they had gluten-free pizza and my huband had their philly cheese sub (and loved it!). The guy that answered the phone when I called in my order was knowledgeable and asked if it was an allergy, and I told him yes. I also ordered it without cheese, and without making me feel weird, he said Ok and within 20 mins, my pizza was done and delicious. I did order ranch on the side, and I think they homemade it because it was pretty watery looking but I tried it and it was delicious as well. I was really worried at first about ordering from here because it doesn’t look super appealing but don’t judge a book by its cover. This place is a must try! I will be visiting again next time I’m in town.
… more
Norman Ross
How do I give a zero star review ! Ordered the pizza , sat outside for 30 minutes waiting for my time it was to be ready (30 minutes) but wife wanted pizza , I wait for pizza. I go to check in at the time the text told me it would be ready. They have never heard of me. Translation , my order hasn’t been started. Their printer machine was turned off and that was their excuse. Customers don’t pay for or eat excuses . So they start my order (30 more minutes). A hand full of other customers got the same excuse and waited , 15 minutes and served. But I’m not a regular so I was put on the bottom of the OOPS list even though I was first to discover the problem and waiting the longest. I cannot see how these will stay open for long
… more
Jon Martin
Great pizza. Four stars on atmosphere because they are not a sit down restaurant (nothing wrong with that).
… more
Megan Loy
Definitely a New Martinsville staple! I love the pepperoni pizza! The PJs special is always great as well. I have to get a pizza every time I’m in New Martinsville!
… more
VALERIE BROWN
Ordered 2 sandwiches, 12 inch. PJ s special had ok amount of pepperoni, but couldn’t t find sausage. Very disappointed.
… more
Zachary Lilly
If I could give it a 10 outta 10 I would. Food was amazing. Only thing I wish was different was if I had some more lol. Highly recommend
… more
Luke Norris
This is honestly what I saw when I opened the pizza box.
… more
Garrett Faught
Terrible, ordered boneless wings and they were undercooked chicken nuggets with barely any sauce to the point you couldn’t even taste it. I also ordered the “new stromboli” and all I could was vegetable oil and to top that the prices are outrageous.
… more
Cary Felton
USED TO BE the best in the valley… Now the pizza is average. The signature “taste” of a PJs special is still there but since when do I want to pay $20 for the half-sized dry pizza that lacks the excess of toppings they were known for. Definitely needed extra sauce and toppings. An XL is supposed to be at least a third larger than the joke I received earlier. Wouldn’t recommend this again. Especially not when I only get to “enjoy” this areas cuisine once or twice a year since moving to NC. Cutting portions AND increasing prices is the wrong way to keep loyal customers.
… more
… View more