Big Apple-style slices, meat-topped pies & basic Italian fare in a simple spot with outdoor tables. Based on 585 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1825 Central Ave, Albany, NY 12205
Phone: (518) 452-9400
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ashvi Patel
Had I Love NY pizza couple times this week, it was delicious! Unfortunately today we ordered an asked for well done and it was a super burnt so was not happy about that. Did not hit the spot! The other day we got pizza by the slice and also got some of the cakes in the case and it was so freaking good! Everything was amazing!!!!!!!! I guess it’s better not to say well done lol just wanted a tad crisper than normal bot fully burnt! Didn’t get to take a pic before tossing. But I highly recommend this pizza it was delicious the firm time I had it!!!! My kids loved it too which is a winner in my book!
… more
Anja Burton
I went in yesterday and they were closing. I completely understood and told him I wasn’t from here and left. The chef came out and offered to make us a fresh one. Which was amazing and so was the pizza. Anytime I’m back in this area I’ll only get pizza from here. Top notch service food and people.
… more
David Smead
Pizza is good. But DO NOT use the delivery service. Placed an order at lunch with a latest delivery time of 5:15. The pizza showed up at 5:45. Called at 5:30 to check on status. Said it would be there in any minute, but did not show up for another 15 minutes. We are on 10 minutes from the restaurant. When called to complain person just made excuses like: bad traffic, construction, everyone calling at 6 to order, compared it to a doctors office and to how busy it is during the super bowl. Was not asking for a refund, but a sincere customer service to offset our negative experience.
… more
Jas P
I ordered an 8 cut pineapple pizza it’s was so good. I didn’t catch the guy’s name but thank you for greeting us in Spanish (Gracías). It’s nice to see people are kind to us. My mom loves the atmosphere on the central ave. She said the chairs are really comfortable, she want to move.
… more
King Sobr AF
Waited an hour and a half for the order. Pizza is ice cold. Almost no sauce. I’ll have to microwave this to even eat it. Not good. Wings have almost no sauce on them but the bag is drenched in buffalo sauce and made a mess. Cheesecake was thrown in a container and is messed up. Awful. First and last time ordering here!!! $50 for this smfh.
… more
Cathy Quintal
Ordered slices while we waited for take out. Pizza maker was also the counter person at that time and he was fabulous . Delicious slices , and everything else ( mozz sticks. Wings ) was delicious as well 10/10 for food and service
… more
Brent S.
Ordered Spaghetti w/ Meat Balls. and Baked Ziti w/ Saugage. It was fabulous.
… more
Jeffrey Salvo
Product is good, only thing is they do not have anyplace for you to clean your hands or even go to the bathroom. I work with my hands and find it necessary to wash my hands before I eat. I thought that was necessary for a restaurant establishment in New York? At least there is as a good pizza spot right across the street with a facility
… more
Alexander Lincoln
I love this place. This shop has tasty slices/pies and friendly staff. they always have tons of pies to choose from if you want to buy a slice too. It’s a smaller shop that is reminiscent of a NYC pizza parlor, which may not be for everyone to dine in, but it’s still a solid place to get food from.
… more
Rebecca S
Made a massive order the day before and everything was ready to go at pickup the next day. No issues. The worker was friendly and thanked us for placing the order with them. All the food was hot and tasty. Would definitely recommend.
… more
… View more