Santino’s Pizza Shack Menu – Elma, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Elma, NY

Based on 149 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Santino's Pizza Shack 14059

Address:
6629 Clinton St, Elma, NY 14059

Phone: (716) 681-1616

Website: https://santinospizzashack.com/

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 12–10 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.		 $7.75
Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza $9.25
Specialty Pizzas
Santino’s Deluxe Pizza
Cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, sweet peppers, and anchovies.		 $13.00
Mexican Pizza
Seasoned beef, lettuce, tomato choice of hot or sweet peppers, mild or hot sauce, topped w/ mozzarella & cheddar cheese		 $15.00
Veggie Pizza
Broccoli, carrots, cauliflower, sweet peppers, fresh tomatoes, topped w/ mozzarella & cheddar cheese.		 $12.25
White Pizza
Garlic, fresh tomatoes, topped with mozzarella cheese		 $11.75
Dandelion Pizza
Dandelion greens, olive oil, onion with mozzarella cheese		 $11.75
Chicken Finger Pizza
Chicken fingers shook in Sauce (hot, medium, mild), Bleu Cheese, topped with Mozzarella Cheese		 $13.75
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Layers of hamburger, bacon, diced onion, special burger sauce, covered in american and cheddar cheeses.		 $13.75
Appetizers
French Fries $3.25
Curly Q’s French Fries $3.25
Seasoned Pot Fries $3.95
Sweet Pot Fries $3.95
Onion Rings $3.75
Onion Chips $5.75
Mushroom Caps $5.75
Garlic Bread $3.00
Garlic Bread With Cheese $3.50
Potato Skins $8.50
Mexican Skins $8.75
Blooming Onion $8.75
Hot Poppers $7.25
Loaded Waffle Fries $8.95
Nachos Deluxe $7.50
Homemade Stuffed Banana Peppers $8.75
Homemade Quesadilla $8.75
Homemade Pizza Fingers $8.75
Homemade Zeet $8.75
Hodge Podge $8.75
Fried Dough $8.75
Mozzarella Stixs $6.95
Soup Of The Day
Please call the restaurant for today’s selection.		 $3.25
Salads
Dinner Salad $3.25
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled marinated chicken served on a bed of crisp lettuce, tomato, mozzarella cheese, onions.		 $10.95
Antipasto Salad
A bed of crisp lettuce, diced ham, capicola, salami, hot peppers, cheese, green olives, pepperoni, tomato, onions and anchovies.		 $10.95
Taco Salad
Seasoned beef served on a crisp bed of lettuce on a flaky shell, topped with cheddar cheese.		 $10.95
Half Pound Sirloin Burger
Big juicy half-pound sirloin burger cooked to order, with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo on the side, served with french fries.		 $7.75
Half Chicken Dinner
Char-Broiled half chicken with BBQ’ d or Plain. Served w/ garlic bread.		 $9.75
Chopped Sirloin Dinner
8 oz. Chopped sirloin cooked to order, smothered with sauteed onions, mushrooms and gravy served garlic bread		 $9.75
Chicken & Rib Combo
Tender pork ribs & 8 oz. Marinated boneless chicken breast, served with garlic bread.		 $17.95
Sandwiches
Hamburger $3.50
Cheeseburger $3.75
Hot Dog $2.75
Fried Bologna Sandwich $8.50
Roast Beef On Hard Roll $8.50
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $6.00
Corned Beef On Rye $7.75
Grilled Reuben Sandwich $7.75
Tuna Sandwich $9.75
Ham Sandwich $9.75
Turkey Sandwich $9.75
Roast Beef On Weck $5.75
Subs
Assorted Sub $6.00
Bacon Cheeseburger $6.00
BBQ Rib Sub $6.00
BLT Sub $6.00
Fried Bologna & Onion Sub $6.00
Cappicola Sub $6.00
Cheese Sub $6.00
Chicken Breast Sub $6.00
Chicken Finger Sub $6.00
Chicken Parmesan Sub $6.00
Chicken Patty Sub $6.00
Fish Patty Sub $6.00
Fried Bologna & Onions Sub $6.00
Fried Clam Sub $6.00
Ham Sub $6.00
Italian Sausage Sub $6.00
Meatball Sub $6.00
Pizza Sub $6.00
Roast Beef Sub $6.00
Salami & Cheese Sub $6.00
Steak Sub $6.00
Tuna Sub $6.00
Turkey Sub $6.00
Turkey Club Sub $6.00
Specialty Subs
Santino’s Royal Sub
Italian Sausage, Ham, Cappicola, lettuce, tomato and cheese w/ mayo (onions and oil on request).		 $6.00
Santino’s Stinger Sub
Diced Chicken Fingers Shaken in your Choice of Sauce and blended with Sirloin Steak And smothered in Mozzarella Cheese		 $6.00
Philly Steak Sub
Grilled sweet peppers, onions $ steak, smothered w/ mozzarella cheese & steak sauce.		 $6.00
Steak & Dandelion Sub
Fresh-grilled dandelion., seasoned steak with garlic, olive oil, smothered with mozzarella cheese.		 $6.00
Fair Style Sausage Sub
Grilled Italian sausage links served w/ slow-cooked sweet peppers and onions served on a toasted roll.		 $6.00
Spicy Bomber Sub
Italian sausage with fried onions, sweet peppers mozzarella cheese with our special spicy sauce.		 $6.00
Polish Sausage Sub
Grilled Polish Sausage links served with Sauerkraut & cheese. ( Does NOT come with lettuce and Tomato or Mayo).		 $6.00
Chicken Caesar Club Sub
Fresh-grilled chicken with crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato and caesar dressing		 $6.00
Burritos
Steak Burrito $4.50
Chicken Burrito $4.50
Pasta
Manicotti With Meatballs $9.95
Stuffed Shells With Meatballs $9.95
Cheese Tortellini With Meatballs $9.95
Garlic Broccoli Ziti $9.45
Lasagna $10.95
Chicken Parmesan Combo
Served with 2 stuffed shells, 2 cheese ravioli, 2 chicken cutlets and 4oz of cheese tortellini and garlic bread.		 $15.95
Chicken
Wings
Layers of hamburger, bacon, diced onion, special burger sauce, covered in american and cheddar cheeses.		 $9.95
Garlic Parm Chicken $11.50
BBQ Chicken $11.50
Battered Chicken $11.50
Charred BBQ Chicken $11.50
Chicken Pieces $7.50
Misc Chicken $7.50
Soft Shell Tacos
Beef Taco $3.00
Steak Taco $3.00
Chicken Taco $3.75
Steak & Dandelion Taco $4.25
Santino’s Clam Shack
Raw $6.00
Steamed Clams $6.00
Peel N Eat Shrimp $7.25
Lobster Dainties $7.25
Shrimp Cocktail $7.25
Alaskan Snow Crab Clusters $7.25
Corn On The Cob $1.50
Manhattan Clam Chowder By The Bowl $3.50
Clam Broth $1.00
Seafood Special
1 corn on the cob, a bowl of chowder and 6 steamed clams.		 $10.25
Slack Tide
12 peel-n- eat shrimp, 6 clams, 1 crab cluster and 1 ear of corn.		 $20.00
Low Tide
12 peel-n-eat shrimp, 12 clams, 1 crab cluster and 1 ear of com.		 $23.50
High Tide
24 peel-n-eat shrimp, 24 clams, 2 crab clusters and 2 ears of corn.		 $46.50
Clams Casino $6.75

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Amy Lohmann
I love their coleslaw. It tastes just like my grandma’s their fish fries are, in my opinion, the best ones in WNY! And they have soooo many things on the menu. There’s literally something for everyone.

… more

Joanne Krickovich
Great pizza and service!!! Our pizza and wings were done on time. The pizza was very good and had lots of pepperoni !!! The wings were also very good!!! Very meaty. We tried the mild Buffalo sauce and it was perfect!!! This was our first time trying Santino’s, and we will be back!!! They also have takeout for beer!!! another plus!!!

… more

Doug
Don’t ever order pizza from here. The previous reviews are correct. This was my first time here and the pizza was RAW!!!! Just horrible. The did refund my money without question at least.

… more

Dan Greene
Just moved close, used to go here all the time when I lived on Bowen Road. The dough is RAW, trying to save it by putting in oven , wings were good.

… more

Junita A
Hamburger taste like McDonald’s meat

… more

Kathy Nichols
Great little place. Doesn’t look like much from the outside, but don’t pass it by. You’ll be glad you stopped!

… more

Barb lis
I liked it ,the food was good I just think beer could come down a bit in price, something like senior specials when you open on fridays,lol we were there from noon till 4 it was nice catching up with Zoe. I miss the people but that’s what happens when you get old. We will come back hope to see you sometime.. Don’t go out much when it’s late.

… more

Kris Kross Applesauce
The steamed clams and fries were good. The pizza was raw dough like an inch in away from the edges but I brought it home and cooked it in the oven. As it being the second day open, they didn’t have clams casino :(. Maybe I’ll be back..

… more

B Greene
I’ve been getting their pizza on and off since 1976, no joke, I grew up on Bowen Road. Best cheese and pepperoni pizza in WNY and it’s still costs around $20.00 – love the heavy amount of cheese and classic sauce…it hasn’t changed at all. Thank you Sandy!

… more

Chris Kane
A fixture in Elma for as long as I can remember… From going with my father as a child, until today. Small town bar, restaurant and clam shack (in the summer) Reasonable prices, great medium wings (very unique sauce), excellent pizza logs. Have a drink and enjoy or get it to go!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch