Bella pizza of Herkimer NY, is under completely new ownership and all new staff. Who are all looking forward to providing much better service, great food and bigger old fashioned sized portions for great prices! New owner’s focus is on quality, great tasting food and a welcoming family type environment.
Come in and check us out. Ask About our loyalty program.
Based on 40 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
122 N Main St, Herkimer, NY 13350
Phone: (315) 219-5219
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
K G
Bella Pizza is remarkably one of the best pizzerias I have eaten from! I placed a delivery order of chicken francese, chicken parmesan, side of meatball and garlic knots. The delivery showed up sooner than expected which was great! I love that the portion sizes are not your typical where it feeds one person only. Each pasta dish lasted me 2-3 days! The chicken francese was so delectable. The sauce was the perfect creamy texture and flavor with the right kick of lemon in it. I was very pleasantly surprised at how thick, and juicy the chicken breast was in both pasta dishes. The garlic knots were also very unique with their larger than a average size and I love that they use real minced garlic on top. The meatballs were so perfectly seasoned and scrumptious that there were no leftover ! Staff members are very friendly, polite, professional, and eager to ensure every customer that walks into their establishment leaves highly satisfied. % I will definitely be going back there soon!!
… more
willxxx
This place absolutely needs to be renovated and thoroughly cleaned. The inside looks very run down. It’s hot and there are A/C in both windows blowing in hot air. The servers are very kind. When I picked up the food and got home I opened the bags to find all the fried foods were very darkened which indicates to me dirty oil. You can actually taste as if they use the same fry oil to fry everything. The burger is honestly a Walmart frozen box burger. The bun was very dry and falling apart. My wife had the antipasto and the lettace- was slightly rotten and lots of other piece being wilted. For almost 60.00 the quality of the food is just very low. I honestly wish the best for you guys there and hope you guys can turn it around. Honestly people work hard for their money
… more
Michelle Geloso
I had the meatball sub and the Chicken Alfredo and both were beyond delicious! Meatball subs can be tricky when it comes to how much sauce there is – too little and its way to dry, too much and it gets messy and makes the bread too soggy. This had the perfect amount of sauce on it! I would have liked more cheese on it, but that’s a me thing, it definitely wasn’t lacking cheese! The Chicken Alfredo was out of this world! The Chicken was juicy and so well seasoned, it wasn’t just random chunks of plain chicken like a lot of places do. And everyone at the place was so nice! I highly recommend Bella Pizza!
… more
Scair Kroh
There’s no way the reviews for this place are legit. The place smells kinda bad & looks really run down. The employees don’t look clean and all look like they’re on a bender. They forgot part of my order. My mozzarella sticks weren’t fully cooked. The pizza smelled weird and was extremely greasy. Low tier gas station pizza at best. I couldn’t even bring myself to eat two slices. I had to go get dinner somewhere else.
… more
My name is Jeff – Spaceposting
The waitress was pleasant and cordial. The atmosphere felt inviting and family friendly despite the small space. I ordered pepperoni pizza by the slice. This is definitely a unique pizza. Each bite felt full, flavorful but not gratuitously so. The cheese brings the flavor, complimented by a rounded out sauce and an unexpected but fantastic note of garlic. The dough is stout but not in a way that resists the flavor ensemble; rather, it compliments it nicely. The crust strikes a balance between crisp and fluff. A pizza that draws feelings of nostalgia. The well blended composition with the garlic surprise earns a 5 out of 5.
… more
Darlene Russ
My order was botched. My seafood platter was missing crab cakes that wasn’t supposed to be on the menu the shrimp and clams were over cooked my grandson’s meal was missing items (Raw chicken) etc… management wouldn’t do anything about this. I don’t think I will be dining with Bella pizza again.
… more
Betty Lou
Food is great. People are friendly.. new owner is nice and polite very professional and courteous. The staff is friendly. Feels like a very homey environment.
… more
James W
I ordered a cheese pizza and cheeseburger pizza both of them were great pizzas. My wife and daughter are picky and they loved the pizza. If you haven’t yet try out there pizza you won’t regret it. They have a great menu of many different pizzas there is a pizza here for everyone.
… more
Jennifer Szuba
I don’t even want to give it one star!!! Absolutely horrible. We called for a delivery we ordered chicken Alfredo Mac and cheese bites and a large cajun turkey sub. I tell them light lettuce tomato provolone cheese mayo and pickles on the sub they tell us 25 minutes for delivery they callus back to tell us they don’t have the turkey so I pick buffalo chicken instead then they callback again and tell us they have no pickles when the food finally arrives and we sit down to eat dinner there are onions on the sub was partially unwrapped with mayo everywhere and the garlic bread was not in the bag for the Alfredo we call them and tell them they finally after ten min on the phone tell us they will remake the sub and have the driver bring the bread and sub back so I tell my boyfriend to eat his food so it don’t get cold well didn’t matttrt cause the food was already cold the alfrado was very watery and absolutely disgusting I will not ever spend another dime if my hard working money on that food again thank you Bella’s for ruining my dinner you guys are the real mvps
… more
KING TAZZTACTIC
To be honest the food is great but only on certain days if that makes sense.
… more
… View more