Locally owned and operated Yonkers Pizzeria is Erie’s newest Spot for New York Style Pizza! We pride ourselves on our Fresh, hand tossed dough, home made sauce and a perfect blend of cheese and toppings! New York Themed and inspired Yonkers hopes to bring a little bit of the Big City to you!
Based on 66 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
3701 W Lake Rd, Erie, PA 16505
Phone: (814) 616-0094
Website: http://www.yonkerspizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 1–6:30 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ashley Hemme
I was very pleased with their pizza! It is thin and big slices covered in pepperoni! The Garlic deep fried dough balls were Absolutely Amazing!!!! I will be ordering these again for sure!!! Perfectly done, and the sauce that came with them is Tangy and perfect as well! Soft and crispy at the same time! Yum! There were 6 garlic balls, but we ate one before taking the pictures 🙂
… more
April Revak
I’ve been putting off giving Yonkers a try due to it being about 40 minutes (round trip) from my house… but after my first order, all I can say is that I regret not making the drive sooner. Literally my new favorite pizza and wings. Everything was perfectly prepared, exactly as I ordered, and truly delicious. Will be back, weekly, I’m sure!
… more
Tina Loncosky
We had take out~The pizza was Amazing!! The garlic balls were also a huge hit! Definitely will go back for the amazing food and great service!!
… more
Lisa Broder
We were struggling to find a good pizza place around town, until we stumbled upon Yonkers! This is the best pizza around! Our favorites are the 3 stooges and the 5 boroughs pizzas. Last week we tried wings there for the first time and they were , as we expected, delicious! Definitely give it a try, you won’t be disappointed!
… more
Jessica
Living in Erie I’ve ALWAYS had an issue with finding really good pizza. And then Yonkers opened this year and I couldn’t be more pleased with their food and their service!!! We order from them every weekend and it’s perfection every single time! I’ve wanted to keep this place a secret for myself since they opened but I guess word spreads fast Eat here! You won’t regret it
… more
Julian Gair
First impression, no this is not Yonkers style pizza. Having actually lived in Yonkers for 23 years I grew up eating at places like A&V, Dom and Vinnie’s, Palisade and lake Ave pizza. That’s authentic. They get it close, and granted I’ve only tried the BBQ chicken pizza that comes with bacon and onions I’ll give them another try in the future. No places in Yonkers serve thin crust and list it as regular. It’ll be explicitly listed as thin crust. Good pizza, but not what I grew up with and not a proper homage.
… more
Jbelly K
They are located where Gino’s & Joe’s was. First time trying their Pizza. I got the “16 Garlic & White sauce, and added bacon and sausage. It was Very Good! The Mrs. & I had a craving for a garlic pizza, and we were very Satisfied! We will be trying their other styles of Pizza soon. I can recommend this New York style pizza to Everyone. It’s really very good! Two thumbs up from Us & 5
… more
Keith Parker
I am diabetic. I like the 3 stooges pizza. My sugar doesn’t spike. The sauce has little sugar in it
… more
Matt Sickert
I’m a gluten for good pizza, and I was hoping the void left by Gino and Joe’s would be filled. I can safely say, it has. The crust was nice and thin with no bubbles. The ingredients seemed fresh and bountiful. The slices were large and in charge. It ticked almost every box for me! My only issue was with the texture of the cheese, but that could just be me. Please check them out, you won’t be sorry, the 5 burgs was a crowd pleaser!
… more
Joey Alward
Delicious food but way over priced. A basket of chicken tenders is $12.99 but French fries
… more
… View more