SALVATORE’S OLD FASHIONED PIZZERIA, ROCHESTER’S FAVORITE PIZZERIA SINCE 1978! Dine-in, take-out and delivery on all our famous full menu items. Pizza Pubs & Saloons. Pizza, Slices & Calzones, Specialty Pizzas, Italian Subs & Wraps, Appetizers, Wings & Chicken, Burgers, Ribs & Plates, Fish, Shrimp & Calamari, Italian Pasta Dinners, Fresh Salads, Desserts, Drinks & Sides.
Area chain restaurant offering creative pies, tons of toppings, wings & Italian subs. Based on 46 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
75 Lake Ave, Hilton, NY 14468
Phone: (585) 392-5555
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Patrick78
Ordered a pizza and 2 orders of wings. Pizza was decent. The wings were 2 different flavors, but they decided to put them in the same container. Brilliant. Not my favorite place in Hilton for pizza, but not the worse. Just remember to speak slowly and clearly when ordering.
… more
Terrance Ray Trybus
All of the Salvatore’s Old-Fashioned Pizzeria locations are locally owned, and the owners are committed to bringing the finest selection of foods to your table. Pizza is always good at Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria, Since 1978. It has been a long time coming, but it was so worth the wait. Thursday’s daily deal can’t be beat.
… more
Josephine DiPisa
Great pizza!! My family and I love the out door patio. It makes us feel like we are on a vacation. When we go, We typically go for lunch with our toddler and the giant connect 4 game keeps our son occupied! Staff is friendly and accommodating too!
… more
Kellylee Kelly
I had ordered Salvatore’s version of a garbage plate. Italian sausage and all mac salad. The mac salad was literally a liquid, of which I’m wearing alot of it. Called pizza place and was told this was normal. I disagreed. I will not be ordering from them again.
… more
Nicole Muscarella
We were excited to try Salvatore’s since it took so long to open, wait time for a large pizza was 45 minutes – 1 hour on a Wednesday. The dough seemed to have been sitting out for hours because it was extremely dry and inedible. Barely any sauce and the cheese was dark. With the over saturation of pizza joints in Hilton, we will not be returning for pizza.
… more
Garrett Oliver
Ordered banna peppers, olives and onion with pepperoni and extra cheese. The cheese was not extra. There was 7 banana peppers total. 15 olives. And a sprinkle of diced onion. And they charge for the toppings. Unimpressed.
… more
CARLO DIPISA
Stopped in with my wife and 2 yr old. The pizza was great and my son was entertained by the giant Connect Four game on the patio. I’ll be back soon!
… more
Don Wenzel
Had some Hilton Salvatores pizza at a friends house for super bowl. It wasn’t bad so when we were looking for some takeout last week we thought we would try one of their $10.00 specials. I ordered a calzone. Mozz., Ham and Pineapple. Ya I’m a pineapple guy. We picked up to eliminate the $6.00 delivery fee and tip. Go home with it only to find that it was 75% Pineapple with a minimal amount of ham. There was a ridiculous amount of dough also. I threw out about 25% of it as just dough. It had obviously been sitting for a while too (cold) even though we waited exactly 45 minutes as the web site suggested. So my $10.00 calzone wasn’t so special after all. I’m not the kind of person that says I will never try again but at this point Carriglios, Carbones and Pontillo’s are looking pretty safe. Got some room for improvement guys.
… more
Grace Romig
A wide variety of delicious comfort-foods.
… more
Joe Burress Jr
It was great. My new goto for pizza!! I met the owner… great guy. He was extremely helpful and the food was fantastic!!!
… more
… View more