Athenian Greek Taverna Menu – Commack, NY

Type : Greek restaurant

Location : Commack, NY

Traditional Greek fare is served in generous portions at this longtime eatery with a homey vibe. Based on 625 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Athenian Greek Taverna 11725

Address:
2188 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725

Phone: (631) 499-7660

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 12–8:30 PM
Wednesday 12–8:30 PM
Thursday 12–8:30 PM
Friday 12–9:30 PM
Saturday 12–8 PM
Sunday 12–8 PM
Monday 12–8:30 PM

Menu

Patio Menu
The Greek Salad – Large $16.64
The Athenian Salad – Large $18.20
Nostalgia Salad – Large $19.24
Horiatiki Salad – Large $18.20
Athenian Spring Roll Salad $20.80
Apollo Sandwich $19.24
Zeus Sandwich $20.80
King George Sandwich $21.84
Rice Pilaf (Lunch / Takeout) $6.76
String Beans (Lunch / Takeout) $6.76
Oven Roasted Lemon Potatoes (Lunch / Takeout) $6.76
Side Of Gluten Free Pita (1) $3.12
Hummus Appetizer $13.00
Grilled Halloumi Cheese Appetizer $16.64
Spanokopita $11.44
Falafel Sandwich $19.24
Yia Yia’s Eggplant $11.44
Fried Calamari $15.60
Little Neck Clams $19.24
Grilled Octopus $22.88
Htipiti Appetizer $13.00
Apps (Dinner)
Grilled Octopus – (Dinner Appetizer) $25.48
Sandwiches & Gyros (Dinner)
The Jack (Dinner) (Cloned) $25.48
Entrees (Dinner)
Chicken Kebab (Dinner) $24.44
Sides (Dinner)
String Beans (Dinner) $6.76
Kid’s Menu
Chicken & Rice (Kid’s) $10.40
Chicken Fingers & Fries (Kid’s) $10.40
Grilled Cheese (Kid’s) $10.40
Gyro Meat & Rice (Kid’s) $10.40
Beverages
Fountain Soda (To Go) $3.64
Bottled Water $2.08
Apple Juice $2.60
Gold Peak Iced Tea $2.86
Frappe $4.68
Coffee (Greek) $6.24
Celestial Herbal Tea $3.64
Coffee Decaf $3.64
Lipton Tea Decaf $3.64
Coffee $3.64
Lipton Tea $3.64
Souroti Sparking Water (Lg) $9.36
Souroti Sparking Water (Sm) $3.12
2 Liter Soda $4.16
Desserts
Baklava $8.32
Kataifi $8.32
Ekmek Kataifi $7.28
Galactoubourek $10.40
Pontikaki $9.36
Cheesecake $10.40
Rizogalo $8.32
Loukoumathes American $12.48
Loukoumathes Traditional $12.48
Loukoumathes Greek $9.36
Greek Yogurt $5.20
Koulourakia (Plain Cookies) $8.32
Kourambiedes (Powdered Cookies) $8.32
Melomakarona (Nut Cookies) $8.32
Appetizers
Pekelia – Cold Sampler $21.84
Bekri Meze – Hot Sampler $24.44
Gigantes Appetizer $11.44
Spanokopita $11.44
Yia Yia’s Eggplant $11.44
Falafel $11.44
Zucchini Chips $10.40
Orzo Sm $10.40
Orzo Large $14.56
Pita Chips $11.44
Potato Chips $9.36
Grilled Octopus $22.88
Pei Mussels In Athenian Sauce $15.08
Fried Calamari $15.60
Little Neck Clams $19.24
Chicken Souvlaki $10.40
Gyro Meat $10.40
Keftedes $13.00
Pork Lollipop $4.16
Loucaniko Sausage $10.40
Dolmathakia (Grape Leaves) $11.44
Dips & Cheese
Tzatziki Appetizer $13.00
Hummus Appetizer $13.00
Htipiti Appetizer $13.00
Skordalia Appetizer $13.00
Taramosalata Appetizer $14.56
Saganaki Appetizer $16.64
Grilled Halloumi Cheese Appetizer $16.64
Tiropitakia (5) Appetizer $11.44
Salads
The Greek Salad – Small $14.04
The Greek Salad – Medium $16.12
The Greek Salad – Large $16.64
Athenian Spring Roll Salad $20.80
The Athenian Salad – Small $15.60
The Athenian Salad – Medium $16.64
The Athenian Salad – Large $18.20
Horiatiki Salad – Small $15.60
Horiatiki Salad – Medium $16.64
Horiatiki Salad – Large $18.20
Nostalgia Salad – Small $16.64
Nostalgia Salad – Medium $18.20
Nostalgia Salad – Large $19.24
Sandwiches & Gyros
Zeus Sandwich $20.80
Yanni’s Gyro $21.84
Lamb Odysseus $21.84
Gyro Melt $21.84
Apollo Sandwich $19.24
Chicken Odysseus $20.80
King George Sandwich $21.84
Falafel Sandwich $19.24
Greek Pizza $19.24
Gyro Melt (Lunch / Takeout) (Cloned) $22.71
Platters
Gyro Platter $28.08
Gyro Melt Platter $29.64
Chicken Platter $27.04
King George Platter $30.68
Falafel Platter $25.48
Plato Platter $34.32
Mt. Olympus Platter $39.52
Entrees
Spanakopita Entree $20.80
Chicken Akrata $22.88
Kota A La Mykonos $31.72
Chicken Athenian $29.64
Kota Me Kapari $29.64
Lamb Kebab $31.72
Beef Kebab $31.72
Taverna Burger $21.84
Steak $39.52
Grilled Octopus Entree $41.08
Little Neck Clams $30.68
Pei Mussels $25.48
Shrimp Kebab $29.64
Shrimp & Salmon Mykonos $42.12
Seafood Carnival $37.96
Yia Yia’s Eggplant Entree $20.80
Stuffed Pepper Yemistes $19.76
Chicken Kebab (Lunch / Takeout)2 $22.88
Sides
Small Avgolemono Soup $4.68
Small Soup Of The Day $5.72
Quart Avgolemono Soup $13.00
Quart Soup Of The Day $13.00
Oven Roasted Lemon Potatoes (Lunch / Takeout) $6.76
Rice Pilaf (Lunch / Takeout) $6.76
String Beans (Lunch / Takeout) $6.76
Side Of Pita (1) $1.04
Side Of Whole Wheat Pita (1) $1.04
Side Of Gluten Free Pita (1) $3.12
Side Of Yogurt Sauce $1.30
Side Of Spicy Yogurt Sauce $2.03
Side Of Dressing $1.30
Side Of Honey Mustard $1.30
Side Of Horiatiki Dressing $1.30
Side Of Athenian Dressing $1.30
Side Of Hot Sauce $1.30
Side Of Tahini $1.30
Side Of Spicy Feta $3.07
Side Of Anchovies $2.08
Side Of Grape Leaves (1 Grape Leaf) $1.04
Side Of Feta $2.08
Side Of Olives $1.04
Side Of Hot Peppers $1.04
Catering Sides & Soups
String Beans (Catering) $41.60
Prix Fixe
Pontikaki $0.00
Rizogalo $0.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Debra Janusz
Friendly attentive service – food came out quickly…so quickly I forgot to take food when it first arrived! Large portion of the Greek salad w pork soulvauki was plenty for two people. Photo is of what was left when we finished eating! Love the mouthwash in the restroom!!! Would recommend

… more

finest M
ask for laura. she’ll make you feel right at home. the food has such a rich taste i keep coming back for more. thank you for treating me and feeding me like family.

… more

John Panetta
I happened to stop in for dinner and there happened to be a trivia night going on what a fun time! (Seems like it’s every Thursday) When you sit down they gave you some pita and tzatziki which was delicious! For dinner I got “the jack of all gyros” it’s like a combo of a gyro melt and spinach pie, soooo good!!!!Bar had a friendly atmosphere and the bartender Sam made a great old fashioned!

… more

Abel Davis
First time at this restaurant and enjoyed everything about it. Great place for lunch and would be an Ideal date night location. Cost is average for the area. The food was delicious and hit the spot.

… more

Venod Narine
We ordered off the catering menu for our staff and it was absolutely terrific. Alex, the owner is extremely accommodating. His manager was a pleasure to work with. The star of the whole operation was the food! It was spectacular. Very delicious and plentiful. We will definite cater from here again.

… more

D M
I ordered a half tray of Greek salad and gyro meat. This is what I received for $115! This is less than a pound of meat, we weighed it. I had to pay for tzatziki sauce which they did not give us and I also had to pay for pitas, which they also did not give me. We will never go back or order again from them! Nope! Done. As is every one of my friends!! I definitely do recommend this restaurant!

… more

Steph T
Strongly NOT recommended!!!

… more

Gail Melisa
I had Mediocre food and weak pineapple vodka. Example: the lemon potatoes were too oily. I sent it back, and the bartender kindly took it off my check. Another example: I have had much better rice pudding. Last example: the $16 pineapple vodka barely had any vodka. DO NOT GO OUT OF YOUR WAY TO EAT HERE. The best Greek Tavernas are in Queens.

… more

Andrew Tardieu
Food was really good! I was mad that I waited so long to try it. I got the Janni gyro with a side of fries, that came with delicious spicy tzatzki sauce. The meat was seasoned wonderfully and every bite was perfect. The pita was lightly toasted but not over crisped which is my preference. My wife had a small Greek salad which was still a very generous portion. Will definitely be returning!

… more

Eric San José
A hidden Gem in Commack. Great food and the best staff /Owners. Great for Appetizers, Seafood, and Gyro platters. Easy to see right off of Jericho Turnpike servicing Commack and the adjoining areas of Suffolk County. Plenty of parking and a wheelchair accessible entrance. Clean facilities. Public Restrooms. Reasonably priced. Desserts are a must. Excellent new location! Highly recommended!!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions