Old-school pizza joint since 1973 providing round Sicilian pies, creative toppings & hot sandwiches. Based on 479 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1731 Crosby Ave, Bronx, NY 10461
Phone: (718) 823-8980
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Xavier Ramos
Portion sizes are terrible for the amount of money they’re charging. $6 for a pizza barely larger than a can of soda. The slice is like the size of a single slice of domino’s for $6!!!. This is insane. Never ordering from here again and wouldn’t recommend it to anyone else who wants some value for their money.
… more
Official Stichel
Ordered from Crosby Pizza Stop for the 1st time ever just to receive an incorrect order, being TRANSFERED 3 DIFFERENT TIMES BY EMPLOYEES, while barely explaining the issue with my order that was paid for, whoever it was on the phone was very extra and belligerent. Could not get anything out WHICH LED TO THE INDIVIDUAL HANG UP THE PHONE ON ME. Will not recommend this location to anyone. IF YOU FEEL COMFORTABLE EATING FROM A PLACE THAT CANT CORRECT THERE WRONG AND ALSO RUDE TO CUSTOMER GO FOR IT. OTHER THEN THAT BUSINESSES WITH RESPECT AND PRINCIPALS IS THE WAY NOT “CROSBY PIZZA STOP”
… more
Philip Federowicz
My other favorite pizza in the neighborhood, next to Joe’s down on Middletown. Always a solid slice with great sauce. Can’t go wrong for a quick slice after work.
… more
Valeria Nieves
Crosby’s Pizza is DA BOMB. Perfection. This is our go-to pizza spot.
… more
John Caraballo
Went here after a medical appointment and was surprised at how good the quality of the food and the service was.
… more
Chris rivera
Okay pizza terrible customer service my mother ordered a Small pepperoni pizza 2 two liters sodas and a grilled chicken Cesar salad. They made us wait over an hour for our food and didn’t even bring the salad. How are you gonna make customers wait that long and forget what she paid for. And then we call them and nobody picks up the phone. This place is not what is used to be. Just order from Franks.For further context we ordered the food at 1:20pm it’s now 2:51pm and we are still waiting for all the food to arrive.
… more
Anagalis Peralta
It’s decent pizza . Honestly I’ve been to many pizzerias and I could say that this place feels extremely peaceful and comfortable to grab a quick slice with your friends. It’s worth it’s price. It’s clean and organized. I liked the visit.
… more
Zay Mayers
Best pizza I ever had in my life. It was cheesey, greasy, and fresh. I cant lie if I ever had to refer pizza it would be this place. Also, the garlic knots were divine. Thanks!
… more
Aida Roman
First time ordered and DISAPPOINTED!! We ordered 4 slices and a beef patty to go. When we get home, no beef patty. We call them and tell them about it and they refuse to recognize the mistake. Bad customer service They insisted on it being in the box. I am sure I know a patty when I see one. There was nothing but slices. Pizza isn’t all that either so good to know. Patsys and Kingsbridge Social are way better anyways!!
… more
Juan Lazaro
I love this place. I truly do but I must say the bald guy who asks for orders, he made me feel awkward he told me listo to order but he heard me speak English before I did not enjoy that not the only time I feel weird when he’s around but great pizza and I hope I didn’t do anything wrong to make him do this against me. thank you
… more
… View more