Based on 125 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
401 Madison Square Dr Suite 21, Madisonville, KY 42431
Phone: (270) 452-2222
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–5 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
rednissan95
Not bad pizza but everything has room for improvement so 4 stars. We had the buffet and it was good and fresh. It was busy so turn around for fresh pizza was constant. The girl at the counter was a sweetheart. Totally an asset to their business. So yes, we’ll be back.
… more
MisfitKat H
This is a wonderful pizza buffet situated in the mall opposite of the Golden Ticket movie theater. It’s staffed by a wonderful group of team members. I have been there a couple times. The staff is always friendly kind and funny. The environment is clean and welcoming. The have a medium to large dining space for events and an open area for normal dining. You can get a pie or enjoy pizza and salad buffet. The food is devious. The have the norms like pepperoni and sausage. While they will even make a pizza to add to the buffet to order. (As available) The salad bar is a simple bar but I think it covers the basics and is always fresh and delicious. They also make homemade desserts. It’s great to have a lunch before a stroll to a movie. The mall is slowly coming back to life and this restraunt is one of the reasons.
… more
Matthew Crawley
I was traveling from Pensacola Florida to Clay Kentucky and we decided to get some pizza and wings on the way to my girlfriend’s dad’s they were on the way and we don’t typically like to buy from your typical commercial run-of-the-mill pizza joints we like to try smaller hometown businesses. They were extremely good they do not hold back on the cheese and the food was ready really fast 10/10 will go back
… more
Gary Salmons
Best pizza in Madisonville hands down. Great people and service
… more
Kevin Kev
I don’t get some of these odd posts. I was just there yesterday and I enjoyed it VERY much. I liked the pizzas and salad bar. For sure the buffet was VERY nice. The place was clean and smelled great. It’s brand new and they are getting in their groove it seems. We loved it. I’ll attach pics. Will go back again this weekend!!!!!
… more
Scotty B
The pizza was phenomenal and the cheese sticks were some of the best that I have ever had. if you haven’t had Scores Pizza you’re missing out. The place is under new ownership. If you have eaten there in the past and we’re not impressed, I think you should give it another try. I don’t know how a person could be disappointed.
… more
Kristi Kulijof
Service is always 5+ stars when Reneé is working. We’ve been several times. The new ice cream bar is very good as well. It’s hand dipped which makes it even better. Pizza is good. Salad bar is a really good salad bar for a pizza place.
… more
rebecca grayson
scores pizza has grown tremendously since it has been under new management. The work environment is so much friendlier and the owners are very family and community oriented. The food quality has improved as well as the variety of items available. The staff goes over and above to ensure everyone has a great dining experience. there are several opportunities to enjoy family nights out either playing trivia or listening to a band . This is not just another pizza place, this is THE pizza place to come to ….
… more
Charlie Hite
Great buffet with pizza, pasta, cheese sticks, and other stuff. Also included salad bar. Food is very good, place is clean, and staff are very nice.
… more
HC Howell
This place is the best pizza buffet I’ve been to in fifty years of eating pizza. The people that work there are very nice and friendly. The salad bar is also great and has a wide variety of things to put on a salad. The cheese sticks are absolutely great.
… more
… View more