Lighthouse Fish Market Menu – New York, NY

Type : Seafood restaurant

Location : New York, NY

Based on 363 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Lighthouse Fish Market 10035

Address:
508 E 117th St, New York, NY 10035

Phone: (212) 320-8894

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–11 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–11 PM
Thursday 11 AM–11 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–11 PM
Monday 11 AM–11 PM

Menu

Pre Fix Menu
Empanada
Chicken or Shrimp
Salmon & Shrimp
Over rice or linguine, with your choice of sauce (ask server for selections).
Lighthouse Punch
Wingettes
(4 pcs)
Butter Garlic Shrimp Linguine
Rum Punch
Crab Cake Dinner
(2 pcs) Crab cake with your choice of 2 sides.
Henny Punch
Blackened Catfish
Choice of 2 sides.
Sangria
Shrimp & Wingette Dinner
Choice of 2 sides.
Margarita
Catering Menu
Sweet Candied Yams
Macaroni And Cheese
Collard Greens
Rice And Beans
String Beans
Sweet Corn
Steam Cabbage(No Meat)
Vegetable
Herb Roasted Potatoes
Mashed Potatoes
Sweet Fried Plantains
Corn Bread
Chicken Fried Rice
Toss Or Greek Salad
Macaroni Salad
Tuna And Macaroni Salad
Potato Salad
Crab Salad
Calamari Salad
Pasta Salad
Peach Cobbler
Cakes
Full
$70.00
Seasoned Fries
Mussels
Crispy Fried Chicken Quarters
Mixed Chicken
Jerk Chicken
Honey Wings
BBQ Chicken
Smothered Chicken
Lemon Chicken
Sesame Chicken
Hot Wings
Curry Chicken
Fried Wingettes
Lasagna Beef Or Vegetable
Meatloaf And Gravy
Swedish Meatballs
Stuffing
Turkey Wings
Baked Salmon
Fried Whiting
Crab Cakes
Clams
Crab Legs
Lobster Tail
Oxtail
Fried Turkey
Roasted Turkey
Menu
Fish Sandwich (3) $8.00
Fish & Chips (4) $12.00
Catfish Sandwich $12.00
All Fish (6) $12.00
Catfish Strips (4) $10.00
Catfish & Chips $15.00
Fish (4) & Shrimp (5) & Chips $19.00
4 Pieces Fish & 5 Pieces Shrimp $15.00
Flounder & Chips (4) $13.00
Flounder & Shrimp $16.00
Scallops & Chips (7) $15.00
All Scallops (11) $16.00
Porgy (LG) & Chips $12.00
Flounder Sandwich $12.00
Flounder Shrimp & Chips $21.00
Shrimp & Wings Dinner $21.00
Fish Dinner $16.00
Fish & Shrimp Dinner $20.00
Shrimp Dinner (9) $19.00
Deep Fried Catfish $18.00
Herb Salmon $20.00
Red Snapper Fillet $18.00
Flounder $18.00
Porgy Dinner (LG) $14.00
Scallops Dinner (7) $19.00
Tilapia Dinner $15.00
Flounder & Shrimp Dinner $21.00
Blackened Catfish Dinner $20.00
Crab Cake Dinner $20.00
Salmon Croquette Dinner $16.00
Basa Dinner $18.00
Catfish & Shrimp Dinner $22.00
Sauteed Salmon Dinner $20.00
All Shrimp
11 pieces
$15.00
Shrimps & Chips
7 pieces
$13.00
Calamari & Chips $14.00
Shrimps, Mussels, Clams, Crab Legs, Lobster Tail & Corn And Potato
Served with rice or linguini or two sides
$55.00
Lobster Tail Stuffed With Crabmeat $47.00
Fillet Salmon Stuffed With Crabmeat $35.00
Clams Stuff With Crabmeat $35.00
Stuffed Shrimps With 2 Sides $35.00
2 Piece Lobster Tails & Chips
2 Piece Lobster & Shrimp
2 Piece Lobster With 1 Side
2 Piece Lobster With 2 Sides
7 Pieces Scallops $12.00
7 Pieces Shrimp $12.00
4 Pieces Catfish Strips $10.00
2 Pieces Flounder $11.00
4 Pieces Whiting Fish $7.00
6 Pieces Wingettes $8.00
1 Piece Tilapia $5.00
6 Piece All Wingette $8.00
6 Piece Wingettes & Chips $13.00
7 Piece Wingette Dinner
Choice of 2 sides with dinner
$17.00
Macaroni & Cheese $5.00
Garlic Mashed Potatoes $5.00
Collard Greens $5.00
Candied Yams $5.00
Seasoned French Fries $5.00
Cabbage $5.00
Yellow Rice $5.00
Cole Slaw $5.00
Macaroni Salad $5.00
Potato Salad $5.00
Rasta Pasta
Shrimp / chicken
$22.00
Sauteed Shrimp Over Rice $20.00
Seafood Rice Paella $55.00
Shrimp Linguini $20.00
Scallops
7 pieces
$19.00
Clams $20.00
Sauteed Mussels $20.00
Calamari Over Rice $20.00
Chicken Alfredo $20.00
Seafood Linguini $55.00
Crab Alfredo $30.00
Lobster Alfredo $48.00
Salmon And Shrimp Dinner $30.00
Salmon Over Rice Or Linguini $20.00
Chicken And Shrimp $25.00
Lobster Mac & Cheese $20.00
Crab Mac $25.00
Seafood Mac & Cheese
Crabmeat, shrimp & lobster
$27.00
Henny Mac & Cheese
Shrimp or chicken
$25.00
Shrimp $1.50
Wingette $1.50
Whiting $2.00
Crab Cake $7.00
Salmon Croquette $5.00
Peach Cobbler $6.00
Banana Pudding Cake $6.00
Coconut Cake $6.00
Assorted Cake $6.00
Banana Pudding $6.00
Iced Tea
32 oz
$5.00
Blue Lemonade
32 oz
$5.00
Fruit Punch
32 oz
$5.00
Peach Mango $5.00
Tropical Punch
32 oz
$5.00
Kiwi Strawberry
32 oz
$5.00
Raspberry Lemonade $5.00
Loaded Lobster Fries $23.00
Lobster Sauce $10.00
EH – Menu Ordering
Fish & Chips (4pcs) $12.00
All Fish (6pcs) $12.00
Catfish Strips (4pcs) $10.00
Catfish & Chips $15.00
Fish (4pcs) & Shrimp (5pcs) & Chips $19.00
Fish (4pcs) & Shrimp (5pcs) $15.00
Flounder & Chips (7pcs) $13.00
Flounder & Shrimp $16.00
Scallops & Chips (7pcs) $15.00
All Scallops (11pcs) $16.00
Porgies (Lg) & Chips $12.00
Flounder Shrimp & Chips $21.00
All Shrimp (11pcs) $15.00
Shrimp & Chips (7pcs) $13.00
Calamari (Fried) $10.00
Calamari & Chips $14.00
Fish Sandwich $8.00
Catfish Sandwich (2pcs) $12.00
Flounder Sandwich $13.00
Shrimp & Wings Dinner $21.00
Fish Dinner (4pcs) $16.00
Fish & Shrimp Dinner $20.00
Shrimp Dinner (9pcs) $19.00
Deep Fried Catfish Dinner $18.00
Herb Salmon Dinner $20.00
Red Snapper $18.00
Flounder Dinner $18.00
Porgy Dinner $14.00
Scallops (7pcs) Dinner $19.00
Tilapia Dinner $15.00
Flounder & Shrimp Dinner $21.00
Blackened Catfish Dinner $20.00
Crab Cake Dinner $20.00
Salmon Croquette Dinner $16.00
Basa Dinner $18.00
Catfish & Shrimp Dinner $22.00
Sauteed Salmon Dinner $20.00
Lobster Tail Stuffed W/Crabmeat $55.00
Filet Salmon Stuffed W/Crabmeat $38.00
Clams Stuffed W/Crabmeat $42.00
Stuffed Shrimps W/ 2 Sides $42.00
Crab Legs Only $30.00
Crab Legs W/ Corn And Potatoes $34.00
Fillet Salmon Stuffed W/Crabmeat $35.00
Clams Stuff W/Crabmeat $35.00
Stuffed Shrimps W/2 Sides $35.00
Combo Meal $0.00
6 Piece All Wingette $8.00
6 Piece Wingette & Chips $13.00
10 Piece Wingettes $12.00
20 Piece Wingettes $22.00
7 Piece Wingette Dinner (W/2 Sides) $17.00
Rasta Pasta (Shrimp Or Chicken) $22.00
Sauteed Shrimp Over Rice $20.00
Seafood Rice Paella $55.00
Shrimp Linguine $20.00
Scallops (7pc) $19.00
Sauteed Clams $20.00
Sauteed Mussels $20.00
Calamari Over Rice $20.00
Chicken Alfredo $20.00
Seafood Linguine $55.00
Crab Alfredo $30.00
Lobster Alfredo $48.00
Salmon And Shrimp Dinner $30.00
Salmon Over Rice Or Linguine $20.00
Chicken & Shrimp $25.00
Lobster Mac & Cheese $20.00
Crab Mac $25.00
Seafood Mac & Cheese (Crabmeat, Shrimp, And Lobster) $27.00
Henny Mac & Cheese $25.00
Loaded Lobster Fries $23.00
Lobster Fries $15.00
Lobster Sauce $8.00
Jerk Mac $25.00
Macaroni & Cheese $5.00
Garlic Mashed Potatoes $5.00
Collard Greens $5.00
Candied Yams $5.00
Seasoned French Fries $5.00
Cabbage $5.00
Yellow Rice $5.00
Cole Slaw $5.00
Macaroni Salad $5.00
Potato Salad $5.00
Shrimp Empanadas $0.00
Chicken Empanadas $0.00
Peach Cobbler $6.00
Banana Pudding Cake $6.00
Coconut Cake $6.00
Assorted Cake $6.00
Banana Pudding $6.00
Red Velvet $6.00
Carrot Cake $6.00
Birthday Cake (Mini Cake) $45.00
Sweet Potato Pie $3.00
Coke $1.00
Sprite $1.00
Ginger Ale $1.00
Water Bottle $1.00
Iced Tea $6.00
Blue Lemonade $6.00
Fruit Punch $6.00
Peach Mango $6.00
Tropical Punch $6.00
Kiwi Strawberry $6.00
Raspberry Lemonade $6.00
Shrimp Empanada $4.00
Chicken Empanada $4.00
Crab Cake 1pc $7.00
Salmon Cake 1pc $5.00
Shrimp 1pc $1.50
Whiting 1pc $2.00
Corn On The Cob 4pcs $2.00
Potatoes 4pcs $2.00
Bread 2 Slices $1.00
EH – Catering Ordering
Sweet Candied Yams $55.00
Macaroni & Cheese $60.00
Collard Greens $35.00
Rice & Beans $40.00
Yellow Rice $40.00
String Beans $35.00
Sweet Corn $30.00
Steam Cabbage $35.00
Vegetables $30.00
Herb Roasted Potatoes $45.00
Mashed Potatoes $35.00
Sweet Fried Plantains $30.00
Corn Bread $30.00
Chicken Fried Rice $55.00
Toss Salad $30.00
Greek Salad $30.00
Tuna & Macaroni Salad $50.00
Potato Salad $50.00
Crab Salad $75.00
Calamari Salad $50.00
Pasta Salad $35.00
Peach Cobbler $45.00
Cake $70.00
Seasoned Fries $20.00
Mussels $45.00
Jerk Wings $65.00
Honey Wings $75.00
BBQ Wings $65.00
Lemon Chicken $65.00
Sesame Chicken $65.00
Hot Wings $75.00
Curry Wings $75.00
Fried Wingettes $75.00
Beef Lasagna $65.00
Vegetable Lasagna $65.00
Meatloaf & Gravy $65.00
Swedish Meatballs $65.00
Stuffing $35.00
Turkey Wings $65.00
Baked Salmon $80.00
Fried Whiting $55.00
Crab Cakes $80.00
Clams $30.00
Vegetable $45.00
Rasta Pasta Vegetarian $65.00
Catfish $150.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Marcus Moore
Little bit of a wait, but worth it. The food was amazing, the shrimp were crispy and crunchy but not over seasoned and cooked perfectly. The Mac and Cheese was cheesy and seasoned to perfection. I also had the jerk wings which were crunchy and juicy, while having a lot of sauce, the candied yams tasted like someone’s grandma made them. A birthday well spent.

… more

rana kingi
We came for mother’s day dinner. The food was fresh and amazing. The service was wonderful. Drinks are strong. For a Monday night they had a DJ and fun vibe. They have plenty of sitting. And fun decor. My only complaint was the music was so loud we couldn’t really visit with each other. We will definitely be back to try other food items. We had fried catfish, fried shrimp and blackened catfish. The sides are collard greens, mashed potatoes, yams, Mac n cheese and potato salad. Generous potions.

… more

Miss Know It All
I have been coming here for a while, but my most recent experience left much to be desired. The cashier is always friendly however I got home to find that my $30 plate of crab Alfredo was made WITHOUT ANY CRAB. Anyone who goes to Lighthouse knows the crab Alfredo comes with chunks of lump crab meat. This plate was literally noodles and cream. To make it worse I bring it back and am told they don’t have anymore crab to remake it for me, and I’m given 8 fried shrimp instead which is almost a $20 difference in price paid. Like seriously?! I’m also just insulted that the person making the food had the audacity to put noodles and cream in a pan that had remnants of someone else’s crab dish and attempt to pass that off as full crab Alfredo to another customer. They clearly did not add ANY crab whatsoever to my dish. Plus my wasted Uber fares to and from to be told I’m not going to have the dinner I paid for. I did my part as the customer and they failed as the merchant. I’ve even recommended them to others, but will not do so again. I don’t want anyone telling me I sent them someplace that plays with their money, time and food. Clearly this is my clue to stop patronizing as it’s the only way I can ensure I don’t pay for food I don’t receive again. This crab Alfredo was below mid. It was trash. Pics attached are of the dish after I turned over the noodles looking for ANY POSSIBLE evidence of crab meat. The two photos are of what I was served (photo 1) and the second is how visible the lump crab is when it’s actually made with crab meat.

… more

Lauren Poynter-Combs
Customer service 2/10: My husband and I ordered wings and was not offered/given any plates. I asked the waitress for blue cheese and never received it. However, one of the other staff members bought us ONE single blue cheese for 10 pcs wings. The cutlery is plastic (cups included). However, the wings were seasoned well and crispy, the seafood boil was tasty and fresh but the lobster tail was over cooked and rubbery. Food 8/10.

… more

Elease R
My Friend had her 44th Birthday party here in the far back party room 8/11 The space was dark and also housed the DJ. There was a older man with braids seated next to the DJ booth with his sneaker off cat calling flirting and yelling loudly for about an hour trying to engage with us, a party of 16 women. It was horrible.

… more

Tiffany B.
The food was amazing. Their bartender was doing her thing! I truly respect the manager, Raymond. They were very busy for a Wednesday night and were short staffed. Raymond went into service mode and assisted in every aspect. Besides the food and drinks being amazing, customer service was surprisingly pleasant for the strained circumstances. I’m definitely coming back, probably in a cab because them drinks were too good, and i couldn’t even finish mine.

… more

Tee Mack
Listen! I don’t usually go out but when I do I always look into the space and details. I’m so glad we came here. If you haven’t been make sure you stop by. The food is out of this world. Lighthouse can take that win now. The staff is even better. Thank you to Malik and Jésus. Your hospitality was noticed and appreciated. We will be back and if you haven’t been, what are you waiting for? Go eat!!! Go drink!!! Get a vibe!!!

… more

El Chelle
10/10 for the quality of the service I spent $26 for my meal and drinks, which included a warm welcome from the personnel and their best efforts to assist you in a timely manner. I ordered mac & cheese and garlic mashed potatoes as my two sides with my order of wings (7 pieces). There was so much food that I was unable to finish it. I requested a drink and instructed the server to blend all the tastes; it was delicious. The Mac and cheese didn’t appeal to me since, in my opinion, it needed more seasoning, but the wings and garlic mashed potatoes were fine.

… more

Nikengie Staten
Food is Amazing! They should ease up on the Salt. The Service was Extremely SLOW,Took Waayy too long to Order/Receive Drinks. Cozy Space,Great Vibes & Suitable for Selfies.

… more

Rashida Shaw
We discovered this treasure in Harlem pre-Covid, but always ordered to go. After dining in for the Seafood Platter, a public review was the next, most logical step. Take it from a Floridian Peach… this place is the truth!!! I found myself almost speechless, hugging nearly everyone involved in the preparation of our meal.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions