Alfredos Italian American Deli Menu – Scotch Plains, NJ

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Scotch Plains, NJ

Based on 153 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $

✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Alfredos Italian American Deli 07076

1800 E 2nd St, Scotch Plains, NJ 07076

Phone: (908) 322-1899



Tuesday 8 AM–6 PM
Wednesday 8 AM–6 PM
Thursday 8 AM–6 PM
Friday 8 AM–6 PM
Saturday 8 AM–5 PM
Sunday 9 AM–3 PM
Monday 8 AM–6 PM

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations



Lorrie McGough
Head over to YELP and get the REAL reviews. Not sure how this place has any positive reviews as one individual said place is trash. This establishment should be ASHAMED. If I could give NO stars I would. Definitely not going back here! This order was take-out. I ordered a roast beef/turkey/Swiss Sloppy Joe and chicken soup. After seeing the one spread of Russian dressing I politely requested to add a little more and was accommodated. Looking forward to a nice sandwich however, I was searching for the roast beef and Swiss… turkey was adequate. In addition, it used to be the norm to get complementary side slice pickle and small side of some salad… in most deli’s. However, not the case here; apparently, it’s an xtra charge. My mom had the soup and said it was good… but the container had a leak; bag was soaking wet when got to destination… might want to check the container when ordering soup.

… more

Bobby Bass
Working in the area and was looking for an alternative to Jersey Mike’s. Ordered half an Italian sub that had plenty of meat & fixings, but just not enough oil/vinegar. Was extremely busy around the noon hour during the holidays, but got my sandwich in a reasonable amount of time. Next time I order the roast beef !!!

… more

Karen Bassillo
Catered a party last week. Everyone raved about the food. Service was excellent. Chicken tenders above all others. They were gone in a second. Portions sizes excellent Good ole deli.

… more

First and last time. Looks like they are going out of business. Employee was very nice though. Got cheese that was pre sliced. Not what I expected

… more

Lauren Stangl
This place was amazing!! Very friendly staff. The BEST classic, no frills sub I’ve had in a very long time. Fresh ingredients, super soft bread. I had roast beef with cheese & horseradish sauce and my partner had chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella and the works. Will definitely be back when we are in the area.

… more

Rachel Lowe
Whenever I order party platters from here, my guests always ask me where I got the sandwiches. Great place!

… more

Michael Prasad
While the name and menu sound Jersey Italian, everything else about this place is not (the cheesy mob TV shows/movie posters memorabilia are really bad and outdated). The staff is the second hardest working crew in Scotch Plains (Subslingers on 22 is better). Can’t figure out if I can park in their back lot, but usually find spots on the street. Not wheelchair accessible, without help. They do have Boars Head products, which is great.

… more

Jimmy Whaler
Great food, tasty fries, and great prices! Owner is super nice (i’ve known him for 4 years) and has a great team of staff. Don’t hesitate to order.

… more

Suzanne Laterra
Best subs ever. It is a ‘must try’ if anyone is on the fence about going.

… more

Vincent J. Amato
Fabulous catering and even everything for lunch is great.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions