Brother’s Pizza Menu – Highland Falls, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Highland Falls, NY

Casual, family-run restaurant offering BBQ & homestyle Southern fare, plus a full bar & live music. Based on 75 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Brother’s Pizza 10928

Address:
233 Main St, Highland Falls, NY 10928

Phone: (845) 446-4988

Website: http://brotherspizzahf.com/

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–8 PM
Saturday 12–8 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Brothers Cheese Fries
Fresh-cut fries smothered with melted monterey jack and cheddar cheeses and topped with applewood bacon.		 $10.95
Becca’s Fried Green Tomatoes
Breaded and fried golden brown just like our sister makes.		 $8.95
Soups & Salads
Brothers Tasty Chili $6.95
Greek Salad $9.95
Sandwiches
Smoked Rooster Sandwich
Chicken breast seasoned with our rub, grilled and glazed in our famous Barbeque sauce. Choose a side: Candied Yams, Cheese Grits, Collard Greens, Fresh Cut Fries, Fresh Slaw.		 $10.95
Gavino Gunslinger Sandwich
Juicy grilled chicken breasts topped with applewood bacon, fresh-cut fries and melted American cheese, finished with mayo, lettuceand tomatoes, piled high on a hero. Choose a side: Candied Yams, Cheese Grits, Collard Greens, Fresh Cut Fries, Fresh Slaw.		 $14.95
Burgers
Brothers Classic Burger
Our classic burger with cheese on a bun. Choose a cheese: American Cheese, Blue cheese, Cheddar Cheeses. Choose a meat preparation: Rare, Medium Rare, Medium, Medium Well, Well Done. Choose an item: Lettuce, Mayo, Onions, Pickles, Tomatoes.		 $10.95
Stuffed Burger
1/2 lb. burger with your choice of cheese stuffed inside and on top, served on a brioche bun. Perfectly melted to ooze when you sink your teeth in. Choose a cheese: American Cheese, Blue cheese, Cheddar Cheeses. Choose a meat preparation: Rare, Medium Rare, Medium, Medium Well, Well Done. Choose an item: Lettuce, Mayo, Onions, Pickles, Tomatoes.		 $11.95
Family Meals
Eat Like The Brothers
Two racks of ribs, 1 pound of brisket, 1 whole chicken (smoked or fried), choice of 1 pound of chopped Barbeque, or pulled pork, choice of 3 large sides, 1 large slaw and pickles. Feeds 3 brothers or 4 – 6 regular sized people. Choose a style: 3 Brothers, 4 – 6 People. Choose a chicken: Fried Chicken, Smoked Chicken. Choose a meat: Chopped BBQ, Pulled Pork. Choose a third side: Candied Yams, Cheese Grits, Collard Greens, Fresh Cut Fries, Fresh Slaw. Choose a first side: Candied Yams, Cheese Grits, Collard Greens, Fresh Cut Fries, Fresh Slaw. Choose a second side: Candied Yams, Cheese Grits, Collard Greens, Fresh Cut Fries, Fresh Slaw.		 $115.95
Eat Like A King
Full rack of ribs, half a chicken, half pound of brisket and half pound of pulled pork served with 2 large sides. Serves 2 to 4. Choose a first side: Candied Yams, Cheese Grits, Collard Greens, Fresh Cut Fries, Fresh Slaw. Choose a second side: Candied Yams, Cheese Grits, Collard Greens, Fresh Cut Fries, Fresh Slaw.		 $62.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Robert Pfister
We used to frequent Brothers Pizza when I was stationed at West Point 30+ years ago. To this day I have never had pizza that could compare to Brothers. I only wish they delivered to Illinois! God bless!

… more

Roberto Vilchez
Best pizza in town. I love this place so much. Staff is very friendly. Love them. And once again, best pizza in town. I live this place. The sauce, the dough, the owners, the price. Definitely give it a try when craving a good pizza slice and are in town. I love that I also can support the local businesses.

… more

Karyn DiSalvo
We have been to all the local pizza places and this is our favorite – nice thin crust and tasty sauce and cheese. My kids especially love getting slices to enjoy right in the shop.

… more

Nicole Toffler
The best pizza I’ve ever had! I’ve been all over the country and to Italy ! I’ll always come back to this town just for brother’s pizza! The pizza taste healthy and you don’t feel heavy after eating a whole pie! I love the salad and all of the fresh sandwiches!

… more

Sean Mulqueen
This is a pizza place that takes me back to the day when my friends & I would go grab some pizza & have a laugh. Fresh ingredients made simple. Hero’s are awesome especially the sausage & peppers! Andy is Very friendly (once you get to know him) but mostly a quiet, soft spoken person. Not alot of money to eat, in fact It is the least expensive pizza in the area. And with its distinctive style, brothers will be here long after others will be gone!

… more

Jalonda Bradshaw
We are very happy with this restaurant the pizza is very good and the prices are also. Definitely recommend.

… more

Dale Barker
The guy was very rude to my wife on the phone when asking about pizza specials. No take-out menu’s, no online menu’s. What a bunch of poop.

… more

Robert “The Vintage Car Show” Henriksen
the best pizza around orange county..closest thing to Brooklyn pizza . go there every time i’m working in the area ,, 2 slices thin and crispy … 1 mushroom and 1 pepperoni

… more

Ron Bennett
Good place to eat. Calzones are the best item on the menu. I’m not sure who the rob j guy is, but his 1* review is obviously fake. You will never get a calzone here that doesn’t have an overabundance of sauce on the inside.

… more

Nicholas Tritone
Honestly a pretty good pizza at a reasonable price. They don’t offer delivery and its a pretty small operation so they just lack the throughput for larger orders.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch