Cacio e Pepe Menu – New York, NY

Type : Roman restaurant

Location : New York, NY

This Italian trattoria features a menu of Roman specialties, plus Italian wines & a patio. Based on 604 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Cacio e Pepe 10003

Address:
182 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003

Phone: (212) 505-5931

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 5–10 PM
Wednesday 5–10 PM
Thursday 5–10:30 PM
Friday 5–11 PM
Saturday 5–11 PM
Sunday 5–10 PM
Monday 5–10 PM

Menu

Antipasti – Appetizers
Timballo Di Melanzane Alla Parmigiana
Eggplant parmesan timballo
$15.00
Polpettine Di Carne Al Sugo Di Pomodoro E Basilico
Meatballs in tomato & basil sauce
$16.00
Burrata, Prosciutto, Tartare Di Pomodori E Gelatina Di Peperoncino
Burrata, prosciutto, tomato tartar, spicy pepper gelatin
$23.00
Zuppa Fredda Di Fave Alla Menta Con Ricotta Di Pecora E Polvere Di Liquirizia
Chilled fava bean soup with mint, sheep’s milk ricotta & licorice powder
$18.00
Seppioline Con Piselli
Cuttlefish with greenpeas
$18.00
Caprese Di Pesce: Bufala, Salmone Affumicato, Lamponi
Fish caprese: buffalo mozzarella, smoked salmon, raspberries
$23.00
Porchetta, Fichi Con Rucola E Grana
Roasted sliced suckling pig with figs, arugula & provolone cheese
$18.00
Insalata Di Cesare
Salvatore’s Caesar Salad
$13.00
Insalata Di Rucola, Pere E Pecorino
Arugula salad with pears and pecorino cheese
$13.00
Insalata Mista Con Fragole, Caprino E Mandorle Tostate
Mixed greens with strawberries, goat cheese & toasted almonds
$13.00
Prosciutto $30.00
Soppressata $30.00
Finocchiona $30.00
Capocollo $30.00
Mortadella $30.00
‘Nduja $30.00
Parmigiano $30.00
Pecorino Tartufato $30.00
Pecorino Ubriaco $30.00
Taleggio $30.00
Provolone $30.00
Pecorino Primosale $30.00
Primi – First Courses
Tonnarelli Cacio E Pepe
Homemade tonnarelli tossed in pecorino cheese & whole black peppercorns
$23.00
Rigatoni All’amatriciana
Rigatoni with tomato, guanciale & pecorino
$24.00
Lasagna Alla Bolognese
Bolognese lasagna
$24.00
Gnocchetti Al Telefono
Homemade gnocchi with tomato & mozzarella
$22.00
Fettuccine Al Limone
Lemon fettuccine
$22.00
Paccheri Alla Carbonara
Jumbo rigatoni in carbonara sauce
$25.00
Strozzapetri Con Gamberi E Pesto Di Fave
Strozzapreti with shrimp & fava bean pesto
$25.00
Orecchiette Con ‘Nduja, Crema Di Cavolfiori E Fave Di Cacao Grattigiate
Orecchiette with ‘nduja, cauliflower puree’ & grated caco nibs
$25.00
Tortellini Con Crema Di Parmigiano
Tortellini with a parmesan fondue
$25.00
Secondi – Entrées
Filetto Di Salmone In Crosta Di Patate Con Zucchine Alla Scapece E Salsa Di Peperoni
Potato -crusted salmon filet with scapece-style zucchini & bell pepper sauce
$30.00
Baccala’ Alla Romana
Roman-style baccala’
$32.00
Straccetti Di Manzo Al Profumo Di Origano Con Rucola, Pomodorini E Patate Arrostite
Beef slices with oregano, arugula & cherry tomatoes with roasted potatoes
$30.00
Saltimbocca Di Vitello Alla Romana Con Patate E Spinaci
Veal saltimbocca with roasted potatoes & spinach
$34.00
Rollatina Di Pollo Con Prosciutto E Fontina, In Insalata Di Fagiolini, Patate E Pomodori
Bread-crusted chicken roll with ham and fontina cheese with string beans, potato & tomato salad
$30.00
Dolce – Desserts
Tiramisu’
Traditional tiramisu’
$10.00
Torta Di Ricotta Con Marmellata Di Mirtilli
Ricotta cheesecake with blueberry compote
$10.00
Panna Cotta Al Limoncello Con Frutti Di Bosco
Limoncello panna cotta with mixed berries
$10.00
Cannoli Al Cioccolato Con Salsa Di Caffe’ E Marmellata Di Arance
Chocolate cannoli with coffee sauce and orange jam
$10.00
Granita Al Caffe’ Con Panna E Cornetto
Espresso Italian ice with whipped cream and croissant
$10.00
Spuma Di Cioccolato Bianco, Frutta Della Passione, Terra Di Cacao
White chocolate foam, passion fruit, chocolate cookie powder
$10.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Jasraj Singh
Wasn’t impressed by the food, felt slightly over priced. Very basic with a little lack of flavor. Was quite disappointed in the lobster ravioli but maybe my palate wasn’t refined for this type of Italian food?

… more

Kamani
Amazing staff, amazing food only thing I didn’t like was that the receipts were handwritten so I couldn’t scan them into my bill splitting app so easy but other than that everything was awesome

… more

Elizabeth T.
We rented the back room for party and it was set up beautifully. We got a variety of “family style” appetizers and a choice between 4 entrees. The appetizers were probably my favorite part, but I wouldn’t call the portions shareable. For my main I got the Orecchiette and I feel like it still needed 2 minutes more to be considered Al dente. It looks like a really nice date night spot and others loved their dishes.

… more

Kristianne Egbert
Amex only – but there’s an ATM. We went for the classic Cacio e pepe and it was worth it. A laid back atmosphere with college students abounding the service was well paced. I had a glass of wine, my daughter and I split the arugula salad, and each had the Cacio e pepe. All of it was everything we wanted it to be. Truly, for the price, of $22, we had a bagel, lox breakfast platter in times square for the same price – so worth it. Portion wasn’t huge but we didn’t leave hungry.

… more

John Hingley
We had a great meal and good times here with friends. It’s a cute place, the servers are very nice and the food is very tasty. Of course we had to order the cacio e pepe, prepared tableside and it was super! We also had the vongole linguini which was good but…the clams were a little large for our taste, and there weren’t many. Still tasted good though. We also had a pasta dish with beet ‘cream’ I cannot remember the name of, but it was really good! Overall a fun experience.

… more

Yvonne Ni
The service was poor and the food wasn’t good. We waited about 50 minutes after placing our orders for our food to arrive. At that point, only two of the three dishes were served. One of the two dishes that arrived was the signature cacio e Pepe. The server rushed the mixing of the pasta on the wheel of cheese and sloppily plated it. Mind you, I’m sitting there waiting for my dish. After plating the cacio e Pepe, he looked at me and said bon appetite. Our entire table sat there confused and wondered if they forgot to put my order in.

… more

Dena H.
Wow wow wow!! This place was nice and cozy with amazing food! Definitely make a reservation as the wait is long. The manager was super friendly and the service was amazing.

… more

Mary Yu
Cacio e Pepe: selling point was the tonarelli (you CANNOT find this pasta outside of Rome even in Italy , let alone New York) the pasta was good, cheese wheel was a nice presentation. However the half sized peppercorns in the pasta was too much. Coarse would be better but huge half size chunks are put in there. Lastly, the price… $25 before tax and tip. It’s just pasta and not worth the price but happy to have tried it.

… more

juana martinez
I had the most amazing dining experience at this Italian restaurant. The cacio e pepe dish they serve is simply divine—I can’t praise it enough. We chose this restaurant to celebrate a birthday, and despite having a group of 12 people, the service was outstanding. The staff was efficient, friendly, and made us feel truly welcomed. To complement our meal, we enjoyed some really good wine from their selection. The highlight of the evening was the cozy and inviting patio where we had a great time celebrating. I highly recommend this restaurant for any special occasion or even a casual night out—it’s an unforgettable experience that you won’t want to miss.

… more

Ashley Nguyen
Pasta was salty but good. Meatball was not soft enough, and does not have good flavors. We enjoyed the bread and their tomato dip more than the main courses themselves. Quite disappointing. Just stick to their signature dish. I saw they brought out the cheese wheel for entertainment purpose. If the food isnt amazing at least you still get some value out of the meal. Also the restaurant wasnt even that crowded, the waiter took super long to take our orders

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions