Based on 182 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
5010 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Phone: (414) 476-7700
Website: http://caradaroclubpizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chris Erbes
I wrote this around 4 years ago, and the food here continues to set the gold standard.
… more
Bob Mattocks
Man alive, talk about a happy accident. We came up looking for a dinner for my wife’s birthday, and literally stumbled upon this joint. We were sat, and the manager Gary came over and started talking with us. He treated us like long lost friends. Such a nice guy, and a great face of the restaurant.
… more
Morgan Trokan
Best thin crust around! Worth any wait on a busy night. I didn’t catch his name, but the nicest man even offered to carry my pizzas to the car across the street, thank you! The mozzarella sticks are wonton wrapped topped with Parmesan cheese & spices, SO good. 10/10 recommend & be nice to the pizza dude.. or no pizza for you!
… more
Sonya Paramore
Visited this pizza joint while in Milwaukee. We were the only family in the place and got great service from the owner. He told us the story of the restaurant and how he became a pizza guy. It was a fun experience and we got dinner for 4 for around $30. We look forward to eating the leftovers.
… more
Brandon Frey
Extremely underrated pizza in Milwaukee. It’s rarely included in standard lists of top pizza places in the city, but it needs to be. The food and service are always great. Plus, you always get your money’s worth. You can guarantee you will not leave hungry.
… more
Gilly GiL
Pizza was good, sauce was more on the sweet side, toppings were fresh, cheese was good, crust was thin. I like a little thicker and chewy crust myself, but its a decent pizza.
… more
Thomas Brunhart
This is really a cozy place with the best thin crust pizza that I have ever had. You can’t miss finding the place…it has a huge coffee cup on the roof that is straight out of the Leave It To Beaver episode where he falls in… :9) The veggie pizza had fresh, fresh, vegetables for my vegetarian better half. I added the Italian sausage on my half to make it perfect! John, the proprietor works like a dog. Cooks, waiters, and delivers beer to the table with a smile. Try this place out!
… more
Riley Stone
First time visiting after ditching a long wait for another pizza spot. Got in right away here and was taken care of! The service was great as well as the food. Good, crispy thin crust pizza and the garlic bread strips were fantastic! Will be adding them to our list of great pizza spots in Milwaukee!
… more
James Matheson, Jr.
Best pizza outside of Chicago and even better than most places in Chicago. Defintely THE BEST PIZZA in Milwaukee. One try and you will know what I say here is true.
… more
Jamie Reese
My husband and I took a weekend trip to Milwaukee for his birthday. I’ve never been to town and was excited to explore! We enjoyed so many beautiful places and foods, 1 of which was Caradaro. We were next door at O Riley’s pub in hopes of getting some delicious Irish cuisine but when we arrived we were informed the kitchen was closed. So we looked up near by pizza and turns out this place was next door. I called and was lucky enough to speak to the owner. He informed me they were slammed and his estimated time for food was about 2 hours. When I told him we wouldn’t be able to wait that long he worked with me to get us a pizza and garlic cheese bread in under 20 min. He was very kind and made the perfect ending to our weekend get away. Although we don’t watch much basketball in STL, we were thrilled to eat the delicious pizza while watching the Bucks beat the Suns!
… more
… View more