Casual hangout for Neapolitan pizza alongside wine & beer in a colorful, diner-style setting. Based on 484 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2144 W 25th St, Cleveland, OH 44113
Phone: (216) 860-1388
Website: https://www.citizenpie.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jaime Chanter
Delicious!! The chef salad was giant and meaty and only $6! The pizzas were very good. My fav was the margarita. We were able to park right out front on the street which was nice. The service was amazing- so quick and super nice guys. Definitely want to return!
… more
DestroyThaCity
Pizza made to perfection. Thin crust slightly toasted. Excellent ingredients and high quality toppings. Good clean pizza that is fulfilling and satisfying. Made the way pizza was made in Rome 2000 years ago. Accept no other; imitation is suicide!
… more
Stephanie M
Wow. So traveling with finicky teens was a nonissue here. The pizza is incredible. Even the chef salad was an experience. The service is cordial and accommodating without being pushy or extra in an awkward fawning kinda way. We just drove 4.5 hours and this was our first meal amidst a days-long road trip. They may all pale after this one. Well done, Citizen Pie.
… more
Netanya Lane
I love the food. The staff was pretty chill but attentive to be sure we love what we are experiencing. We ordered the New Yorker and I melted in my seat. If you want to travel to Italy without leaving Cleveland, go to Citizen Pie. The crust was crunchy outside and soft inside. And it’s crunchy when you bite into it and the cheese stretch is . I will find my way back to get more pizza. Sorry, Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, and Domino’s. Citizen Pie is top tier for delicious and authentic Italian pizza. I recommend the New Yorker. I would love for them to have more alcohol options like Smirnoff bottles or wine coolers. We had the White Claw.
… more
Metehan Erdogan
I loved the Margherita! The prices were pretty decent and staff was friendly.
… more
Tasha D
I ordered the “New Yorker Pizza” via Uber eats. I added on Burrata from the menu to put on my pizza and it didn’t disappoint. Very fresh and creamy taste. This pizza was absolutely delicious. However next time I’ll get it in person. The coke I ordered with the pie was pricey. It was $2.86 nearly (3$) for the can nevertheless this was a great lunch.
… more
Rikki N.
Chill atmosphere, although a bit cramped. The pizza was amazing, everyone in the family loved it. The kids enjoyed watching them toss the pizza dough in the air as well as their pizza. Overall it was a bit pricey, but worth it for the quality, fresh wood fired pizza.
… more
Breanna Farrar
The best pizza I’ve had in a long time! I love that they didn’t alter the original building inside. The food was so good and it’s great being able to see your pie cooking in the stone oven. Stopped by after going to the West Side Market which is right down the road. Definitely recommend!
… more
Anna Unke
OMG SO SO SO SO SO GOOD!!!!! I have an allergy and they were sooo nice. The space was supa cool, the workers were soooo kind and nice and awesome. The food was 10000000/10. Best pizza ever. Coming back asap. Beautiful crust that’s to die for. Perfect taste and texture. A true wood fire pizza place
… more
Claudia Hallam
This place is impressive! Not a ton of tables so it probably fills up fast. Staff is friendly and the pizza is incredibly delicious — the crust is cooked well and has a nice chew — toppings were fresh
… more
… View more