Based on 166 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
749 Park Ave, Columbus, WI 53925
Phone: (920) 623-2300
Website: https://www.dayonepizzadelivery.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Erik Fisch
The sauce. The crust. The cheese. This place puts all the pieces together like not many can. The sauce is perfect in my opinion and the crust is potentially the best hand-tossed crust I have ever had; it is light, crispy and chewy.. perfection. The cheese is great and the amount is even better – most places put too much cheese on but these guys nail it. The only critique I have is that they put the toppings under the cheese, which personally I will just never understand.. but they are always happy to put toppings on top if requested so it’s not an issue! This place is the real deal!
… more
Matt Starr
Wonderful pizza. They really nail the hand-tossed crust thickness and balance of all flavors in the cheese and sauce. The leftover pizza also heats up better than anyone else’s, period. Been our family favorite for years, and the owners are incredibly kind.
… more
Rancorous
Pizza is good. I got mine in about 9 minutes after I ordered it so the service was fast.
… more
Nichole White
10/10 on food, especially their breadsticks. They also have awesome customer service and were more than willing to stay just a couple extra minutes late for us to pick up pizza while we’re in the middle of moving.
… more
Adam Jensen
Great pizza place and staff. I tried the Taco and pepperoni when I was traveling through the area. I enjoyed the authentic pizza parlor feel.
… more
ilovetotri23
Sometimes I like to go simple. Just cheese or pepperoni. But the Taco pizza too good! Garlic breadsticks are a must have! Everyone in my family always wants food from here!
… more
Tom Osburn
My favorite pizza. Worth the drive. The people there are so friendly.
… more
Chelsea Plummer
First time ordering from here. Pizza was very good! Perfect amount of toppings and sauce. Delivery was fast, within 30 minutes of ordering.
… more
Cheryle Pederson
My order was going to be 1338 and they wouldn’t deliver it because their delivery charge minimum is 1350 my boyfriend just died and I was hungry and I couldn’t get my pizza delivered because of a few cents I will never ever buy a pizza from this place again
… more
Drew
I’m updating my review as their customer service has greatly improved since my last visit/review. The food is great, and I’m particularly fond of their pans of macaroni and cheese as well as their cheese bread. I highly recommend stopping by and giving them a try.
… more
… View more