Based on 187 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
66 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596
Phone: (516) 747-3413
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
john d Lin
Would give 5 if it were my local pizzeria. Drove a while to try their upside down pizza after hearing super reviews. I’m sure if it were fresh out of the oven it would taste better. Still, it was goof but not to die for. Sicilian is good too, but there is only sauce in the middle and than cheese ontge sides. Would be better if there was sauce throughout. On the more expensive side for places, due to the neighborhood.
… more
Enrique Mosre
Frantoni’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a small place with informal dining. Most customers come for takeout or slices which they buy from the counter and sit themselves at the bare top tables. The place offer various sodas, about four different beers, and one white and one red wine by the glass. In the time we were there (Saturday 19:30,) we did not see table service. You have to get up and retrieve your order from the counter when the food is ready. We ordered a Grandma pie, two different bottles of beers, and ate with plastic utensils and paper plates. The service was friendly. As to the food; the Grandma pie was ok; not great; it lacked crispness (pizza pan insufficiently oiled?.) We asked that they cook the pie some more to achieve the crispness of the topical Grandma Pizza, but as son as it cooled down a little, it went limp again. The tomato taste of the pizza lacked the typical acidity of the tomatoes of San Marzano (I do not know which tomatoes they use.) The mozzarella was mild, and the thickness of the dough was as a Grandma pie should be. Overall, if you were to close your eyes while eating the pizza, it could pass for a regular NY style pizza, you could fold the slice and eat it!. We will not come back to this pizzeria for Grandma pizza, but for a regular slice and the friendly counter service.
… more
Robert Mui
I moved to LI a few years back from Brooklyn, and there were a lot of good pizza joints back where I used to live. Finding a good joint near me in LI took a few tries but I’m glad I found Frantoni’s. It’s good enough to satisfy my cravings for pizza and has become my go to to for pizza.
… more
samanthababettegray
Ordered here after 2 people in the same day recommended. We ordered the chicken vodka sauce 18” I like that the pizza was large and had a decent amount of toppings. Unfortunately, it was burnt and disgusting. After taking a bolus of insulin before eating my 2 slices I discovered that it was burnt on the bottom and inedible. Obviously we didn’t have other dinner plans or food to cook for the night and I ended up eating a bowl of cereal so I didn’t become hypoglycemic. Probably not your typical review but we won’t be back.
… more
Ron Sans
Ok, pizza was good, but I know that I didn’t order any screws!
… more
peter Ickowicz
Great pizza, have been coming here for 20 years!Owners are friendly and pleasant, pizza is excellent, perfect crust,non-greasy.
… more
Demir Mehovic
Stopped by this place on a whim and I was pleasantly surprised. My girlfriend and I ordered a slice of the buffalo chicken, chicken Marsala, Gorgonzola, and chicken garlic pizzas and still can’t decide which slice we like more. They definitely don’t skimp on the ingredients and every pizza is uniquely made to distinguish itself from the last. For example, each slice we tried that had chicken on it, the chicken was prepared differently. Other than that, the place looks clean and the staff are very friendly, would highly recommend!
… more
Muniz Media
Alway a good experience at Frantoni’s. Good food and the folks are there are great. A true neighborhood pizza joint with amazing combinations. I stop in whenever I’m in the neighborhood!
… more
Mike Mastro
Glad we found this place! One of the only pizzerias I know that has a great menu for gluten free pizza and much much more GF stuff.
… more
bradley d
My post is a little late. We ate here several times about a month ago and we’re not disappointed. The guys behind the counter were very friendly and attentive. The pizza is delicious ranging from just plain cheese pie to specialties. Lastly I like the fact that the owners respond to the reviews. I used to go to Mama Teresa’s as a kid but their service and attention to the customer seems to be lost. I will continue to go to frantoni’s when I’m in town.
… more
… View more