Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering calzones, sides & desserts. Based on 44 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2351 N Centerville Rd, Centerville, IN 47330
Phone: (765) 855-5849
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Matthew Roman
I had a pizza that was very under done. I called and offered to bring it back for a refund but the manager offered to replace it. The second pizzas I got appeared burnt on top but was actually very good. I assume theyou are having oven issues because they have a difficult time cooking the pizza evenly. However the quality was good and the manager was very helpful. Overall I give it a 4/5 the manager on duty really saved the day here, OK pizza, great service, at least from the manager.
… more
Neo Shadow17
This is the best pizza place ever, me and my mother love to go there. The pizza is always perfect when we get it and the employees are very nice. The cashier that served us today even apologised for the 25 minute wait, which is not a very long wait when it comes to pizza. He even told us to enjoy the pizza and have a nice day, I would pick this resturant over the dairy queen next door in a heart beat. They are also very generous with their pizza toppings.
… more
Samuel Mount
Pizzas were great…they certainly didn’t skimp on the cheese. Service from staff wish quick, efficient, and fairly friendly. Cooking and deliver to counter was very slow-20 minutes plus. That’s why I deducted 1 star.
… more
Sterling Greni
Very disappointed with the service here. I will never visit this Godfathers again. Basically I was traveling through the area and stopped here to get fuel and lunch. I ordered a mini taco pizza and was informed that it would be about 10 minutes. I patiently waited for 40 minutes while the 2 employees slowly went about their business with no indication that it would take longer. The restaurant was not busy; I can only assume that the employees simply don’t care and the owner doesn’t want to be in business very long.
… more
Cindy Dotson
Drove 30 – 40 minutes,,, because we like godfather’s,, the woman who waited on us was so RUDE!!!! They didn’t have any crust but personal size,,we asked her the size and she made a size with her hands and said “about this before big” really mean tone!!! Threw her order form on the counter and told the other to take our order,,,so we got what was already made,,4 pieces that we couldn’t eat be cause the meat was so hard and dried,,,so we went to McDonald’s,,,
… more
Buffie Rea-ROGERS
Really good pizza once in a while we call and order a pizza and just enjoy the drive to pick it up on the weekend cause it’s off 70. But worth it good price to.
… more
Bobby Banis
I tried to call and order but they wouldn’t answer the phone. I went in to order and it was immediately obvious that there was no interest in serving customers. There were no other customers and the lady said it would be at least a half an hour wait. Employees are just to lazy to serve customers, why even be open? Never again!
… more
Molly Jones
Their pizza is always good..sometimes they miss extra ingredients, but still sooooo good!
… more
June December
In my opinion Godfathers pizza is the best I’ve had. Always good regardless of location. This particular place is fantastic
… more
sheila shaw
Food is always good when you can order.
… more
… View more