Late Night – Authentic Italian Food, Brick Oven Pizza, and Over 50 Bottles of Wine to Choose From! The Only Restaurant in Sackets Harbor, NY Open Year-Round. Boasting a Warm Atmosphere, an Innovative Sunday Brunch, Fresh Ingredients and Scratch-Made Desserts and Dough, and Unmatched Customer Service.
Based on 800 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
202 W Main St, Sackets Harbor, NY 13685
Phone: (315) 646-3463
Website: http://www.goodfellos.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4 PM–12 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 4 PM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Marion NYC
Great service! Wonderful restaurant space! The food was delicious. The area too
… more
Tommy McGuido
Ok. Got in late tonight, and 4 people were starving. The place we usually go to was closed. So we had to get this or McDonald’s. McDonald’s is straight poison. So we went here for pizza. And 42 dollars for some of the worst pizzas I’ve had in New york is just ridiculous. I know Sacketts harbor is a bit pricey to begin with due to the type of people it attracts. And I’ve paid good money for nice thick crust artesian pizza and been very satisfied. This is an outrage. This is a thin crust, not even crispy like a good NY thin crust pizza is supposed to be. So, there is no money in the dough. Asked for extra cheese, and it was the same as the pizza with no extra cheese. Nevermond that they’re smaller than a damn digorno pizza. I’d pay 10 per pie tops knowing what I was getting, and I’d still be reluctant because there are way better NY pizzas with actual crispy dough and crust. So I warn anyone who is interested in getting what they pay for to stay far, far away from this place. I ate 3 slices easily. My sons both ate half the other and were instantly looking for more. And my wife actually ate all three slices. And our family always jokes because she only ever gets through one and a half tops.
… more
Marc Shoemaker
We were recommended to eat here at this local restaurant and we’re not disappointed. The service was outstanding as we were seated right away outside. The menu had a big selection of items, especially if you are a pizza fan.
… more
Angelique Rose
They have Tiramisu, Pizza, Pastas, Drinks, Good Sized Appetizers, and it was so nice to sit outside.
… more
Juan Mendoza
I’ve been coming here for the past year. Had always had a great experience.
… more
HKN90
My friends and I decided to go to Goodfellos, after it was recommended to us by a coworker. Right when we walked into the restaurant, we were greeted by numerous friendly waitresses who wanted to know if we were being helped. Because we were a party of 8, it took a few minutes for the staff to ready the table. Upon being seated, our drink and food order were taken down and placed. Even though the restaurant is a bit pricey, I decided to try a few different items. I ordered the Smoked Duck Wonton, Pork Milanese, and the Tiramisu. All three plates were very tasty. My friends also enjoyed their meals as well.
… more
Beth White
We had a nice dinner here during holidays ..very pretty inside with white lights and decor . Tracy, our server was friendly and responsive. I love the atmosphere here .. especially during winter.. but the food is underwhelming. I wish they would change up the menu a bit . Dinner for two was 90.00.
… more
Mari Maxon
I love coming to good fellows whenever we are in the area. Although a little expensive, the food is absolutely amazing. We usually get takeout and I always get the same pizza (the favorite), but during our most recent visit we ate at the restaurant. It was crowded even on a Tuesday but we still got an outdoor table that wasn’t in the middle of all the commotion. My father and I both decided stray from our usuals we ended up getting pasta and it was just as good if not better than the pizza. Going to good fellows during our visits to Sackets Harbor has become a great family tradition, one that I hope will continue for a long time.
… more
Tristin Crum
A 3% fee to pay with debit or credit is ridiculous, charge what you need to cover this cost
… more
Rob Wilson
This is a place to avoid unless you’re willing to eat an extremely undersized and overpriced food item, along with beverages that are equal in stature.
… more
… View more