Based on 429 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
14919 Tamiami Trail, North Port, FL 34287
Phone: (941) 740-8269
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kristina Graham
This is our favorite local pizza joint! We usually go off times during the week and get the owner behind the counter. He’s the nicest guy! But the food is top notch, just how I remember the mom & pop pizza shops up North. We’ll be back regularly
… more
Dean Petow
The young man taking orders at the counter today needs some time off or maybe another career choice. He couldn’t have been more unfriendly. The pizza was ok but luke warm same person through the slice in the oven but didn’t let it warm up. The pizza was decent, maybe a 6 out of 10, would be higher, maybe if it was served hot. Hope management can offer some trying to this particular employee or help him find another job. Visited here 3/21/23 around 1pm
… more
jon spears
Proper New York cheese slice!!! Tried some other options as well. Did pepperoni and sausage with red sauce. My wife did the rigotta cheese base pie with mushrooms and onions. Everything was delicious!! The fellas working couldn’t have been nicer. My also did the chocolate covered canoli. Well done libero!!
… more
Stephanie Cain
Just got 2 Sicilian pizzas from Long Island brothers, it was AMAZING!! I could tell it was just made, the dough was very flavorful and soft on the inside and a little crispy outside. They put just enough sauce which wasn’t acidic and had a wonderful taste. It was cooked to perfection!! Definitely ordering this again and telling everyone!! Good job guys!
… more
Jarett Chizick
Great service, friendly staff, amazing food (see pictures)! First location in the area, planning for a second in venice. New York style pizza almost as good as the real thing (it’s all about the water). I’d recommend it over the pizza place two doors down without hesitation. They do close sooner than most pizza places in the area, so plan ahead. They will take orders right up until closing at 8pm though, but do call or order sooner out of respect for the employees (they work hard and go above and beyond to give great service). Will be back to try the calzone!
… more
Rocco Napolitano
Been down here 2 years. FINALLY good pizza. Real NY/NJ style pizza. Found my spot!! Finally. So tired of people telling me all these other places are good. Tried them all. THIS is what you want! Thank you.
… more
Platez
Customer service was amazing. Super friendly and they were glad to go the extra mile for the customers. The food was awesome. The pizza is amazing with what I find to be the perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The crust was also excellent. The honey hot wings and the cheesy bread were spot on as well. The chocolate peanut butter cake was top tier. Good cannoli as well. Everything tasted great truthfully. The place itself was very clean and had a very cool feel inside with the wall decor. Overall just great place, would give a 6th star if I could.
… more
Cosmo Kogan
Vacationing down in Florida, raised in upstate NY, eaten in Long Island, and pizza shops everywhere. The regular cheese NY style pizza was on point and takes just like it did back home. For me(personal taste) the gramma pie fell WAYYYY SHORT. The cheese was rubbery, the crust wasn’t cooked in a oiled pan, and the sauce on that pizza was basically just a pasta sauce not a chunky San marzano sauce, honestly it was terrible. The guys at the shop were very friendly.. however I wouldn’t get that grandma pie there again. I would however go and get their regular pizza again.
… more
Joshua Peterson
I don’t know what happened with this name change. I know the pizza changed
… more
Sergio 1k
Ordered two pizzas both came raw. Now just imagine being super hungry you order food and it comes raw like I can get my money back but now I’m super hungry and mad really is super lame and on top of that it had more garlic then anything…
… more
… View more