Based on 74 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
Address:
2167 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954
Phone: (631) 238-5469
Website: https://www.mortysoysterstand.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
susan able
So glad we made the choice to pull in here for a lovely, relaxed, oystery and boozy lunch. It’s got the perfect Montauk beach vibe and generous and delicious frozen drinks. Try the calamari. And enjoy the design and custom made wall paper!
… more
Hrair Seropian
I read some of the reviews here where they gave 1 or 2 stars and I think that’s an unfair rating. The restaurant decor is really nice and chic, the staff were personable and very friendly, the drinks were a bit pricey, food options were great and balanced. We mainly tried the seafood options and the quality, taste and presentation was very satisfying.
… more
Marina Dmitrieva
Nice place, service was ok.
… more
Ariel Rosenberg
Wonderful setting, very good food, although a bit on the pricy side.
… more
Thatcher Shultz
Absolutely epic new roadside restaurant on Montauk Highway, everyone has been freaking out about how good the food is and now I know why. It’s unreal, and the service was perfect. Bravo
… more
Beth
The oysters were fresh and delicious but the lobster roll was extremely skimpy and just ok. My friend loved his crab cake. Dessert was disappointing. In general, it’s overpriced for what you get.
… more
Shelby Martello
This place was such an amazing find. We were visiting for a wedding and had a free day to find some lunch and came here. We had the oysters, fish tacos and tried two drinks all of which were amazing. They had the absolute best service too. Very fast and the servers were so incredibly nice.
… more
Natalia Nakazawa
This place was excellent on every level – ambiance, food, service – we had a wonderful time! I highly recommend the oysters, fish and chips, ceviche, and the key lime tarte. They even had a kids menu! Lovely experience
… more
Carolyn Zapp
The food was fresh as can be and the flavors were delicious and uncommon. Steamers steamed in lemon and thyme were terrific. We had a tropical rum drink that made us feel like we were truly on vacation and the vibe Cyril left behind was palpable. We loved the place.
… more
Mordechai Gabay
The only reason I gave this place two stars and not one is because the food quality is decent.
… more
… View more