Based on 228 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
164 S State St, Shelley, ID 83274
Phone: (208) 357-5560
Website: https://mapstuk.top/mr-pizza-s74cyq
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
7 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael Roberts
In Shelley on Highway 91 is this treat of a Delectable Pizza! Stop By… You won’t be disappointed!!
… more
Can Cook
All of these “Local Guides” leaving 1 star reviews have to be a joke. Mr. Pizza is good. I was introduced to the pizza Shelley Chiropractic gets for there staff meetings and I am hooked. Their Hawaiian with white sauce and banana peppers is divine!
… more
Jessalyn Dye
If you haven’t had the Breakfast Pizza and the Cinnamon Sticks! You definitely should! Great owners and brings a sweet community feel!
… more
Larry Brittell
Pizza was ok but cheap. Stopped in to cool off on a hot day to find out it was even hotter in there
… more
Eden Waldron
If I could give this place a -10 I would. Dirty, the pizza was like cardboard with no flavor, the ranch looked like and tasted like milk with nothing else in it. The service was horrible. When their ice machine was not working, I asked if it was out and the kid goes “I don’t know probably” and walked off. They gave you small white styrofoam cups for soda and you had to use tinfoil squares to take your leftovers in. Nothing at all like the Mr. pizza in Blackfoot.
… more
Kathie Averett
Disgustingly dirty, ranch looked like milk and couldn’t even eat the salad as they served brown lettuce. I wiped the table off with a paper towel and it was completely brown. Ordered largest pizza and it was 3 inches in from the outside of the pan.
… more
kevin
The people are always nice. The food is always delicious. I love going here they are always inviting. Definitely will be back!
… more
Vicki Raywinkle
Worst pizza ever… NO sauce. Even called to tell them no sauce and still just a brushing of sauce. Will never go again.
… more
Brooke Orner
The best pizza I’ve ever had! I’ve always loved Mr Pizza, but they have really stepped their game up lately. Breadsticks are the best!
… more
Darrell Ingrum
Love this pizza! The proprietor is really nice, the decor and wonderful pizza smell is nostalgic of another little pizzeria where I hung out as a kid in the 80’s in Ky, and he even plays (at least when I’ve been there) an 80’s pop station on the radio, so it’s like a time warp! Toppings on the whole pizzas are generous and very flavorful; the pizza’s for the $2 lunch special are one-topping (so not my fav), but you get a big slice, big breadsticks, and refillable drink, so it’s actually pretty filling and perhaps the best value I’ve ever seen.
… more
… View more