Pizza parlor with a patio serving thin-crust pies & other Italian-American eats, plus craft beers. Based on 736 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
76 Bay St #2511, Staten Island, NY 10301
Phone: (718) 447-7437
Social Profile:

Hours
Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alison Thornton
Fried calamari salad. Delicious. Moreish sweet taste. Calamari not overwhelmed by bread/batter. Lots of leaves and tomatoes. Great portion size. I didn’t need to upgrade. I was hot and grumpy when we arrived here. Yummy food and good service made everything better. My dining companion had the best buffalo wings ever and the best pizza outside of Naples (super thin crust) Thanks Danny for the recommendations.
… more
janice
Gem of a place. A locals’ hang out. You know it’s a great place when you see New York Transit workers frequent the place (bus drivers know best.) Small distance away from the Staten Island Ferry, but worth it to go and taste. They have vegetable sides to make it healthy. They have cauliflower crust so enough locals must ask for them. Pizzeria is right next to the bar so you have a choice to just order the pizza to go or to eat inside. Limited outdoor seating. Come and see what you are missing.
… more
Basma Z
Excellent food and service. The staff is incredibly helpful and friendly, specially Katie. Will definitely go again everytime I’m in staten island !
… more
Carlos Daniel Rocha
Great food, even better service. Very nice restaurant and real food is served here.
… more
scott wells
On a whim we tried the fried calamari and spinach salad pie (thin crust). Best pizza I have had in years. Outstanding. Tons of perfectly cooked calamari and fresh spinach salad. Slightly challenging to get into your mouth but worth it. Excellent service. Crowded and a bit loud for conversation but will return for that pie again.
… more
Many Attitudes of Dennis
The perfect rating is a must simply because of the marriage between price point and quality. The regular cheese pie at Pier 76 is top notch taste and Monday through Thursday there’s a $10 pie special ($10.99 with tax). The thin crust, the cheese, and the sauce all high-grade. It’s an unbelievable deal, the $10 special, and that’s what I always get and that’s why I’m giving 5 stars. There’s two other pizza places on Staten Island that really impressed me: one, Paulie’s on Bay St, is out of business. The other one, the well known Joe & Pat’s, is very good but rates slightly lower than P76. P76 has better location too, right across from ferry. And J&P weekday special is $2 more. And last but not least—the sauce—sauce, I feel, gets overlooked when it comes to pizza, but that’s what really separates ok pizza from great pizza. P76 pie has good sauce! I’ve also tried the calamari once and I would get it again; I enjoyed it, however, the calamari costs more than a pie and I pretty much plan to keep spending $10.99 for a great pizza as long as I can!
… more
Keni Catalonia
Good food, good prices. The waiter too serious.. Gluten free options but some not available, and they told us once only we had already ordered.
… more
Rob Wilson
We found out about this place from someone that grew up on Staten Island. We stop by every chance we can. The Italian is AMAZING. the pizza is some of the best I’ve had and their pasta is top notch. We were most recently there after the 5 boro bike tour and with 32k riders ending at their doorstep, they were swamped. Even with the crowds, they delivered great for in a fun place. Can’t wait for the next time I’m nearby!
… more
Jerry Rosa
The pizza was good (thin and crunchy crust), but the places was understaffed. The bartender had to take care of the customers at the bar and also serve as waitress for the people sitting at the tables. I would return to the pizzeria, but not the bar.
… more
Stacy Stevenson
Buffalo pizza has a unique sauce and cracker like crust. Gluten free pizza available. Homemade Mac n cheese was great for the kids. Open late
… more
… View more