Based on 59 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
282 Middletown Rd, Waterford, NY 12188
Phone: (518) 233-0601
Website: http://www.halfmoonpizzaplus.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 12–9 PM |
Reviews
wally
I order 1 -2 sausage pizza a week… Always ask EXTRA CRISPY. Means leave it is the oven longer then normal…
… more
tamika rosario
The exact reason why I don’t buy food in this area.I ordered 25 wings half buffalo that taste like ketchup and 25 garlic Parm with a whole bunch of garlic with no parmesan. Please fire that cook asap!
… more
Kyle bob
I just tried to call (at 750 pm)to order a pickup order and even though Google has the closing time listed as 9pm I was greeted with “hi sorry we are actually closing up right now” and hung up. I’ve been waiting all week for my day off so I could get the kingsteak sub I’ve been craving and called during business hours. I’m a cook at another restaurant, and we’re almost always understaffed but that has never meant we just go home early. This is a ridiculously bad business move. Quick and easy way to lose customers is to be closed during the hours you advertise you are open during. I’ve been coming to pizza plus for 20 years and never have I been so disgusted.
… more
Torri VanNostrand
The pizza is always great but the young man who answers the phone really needs some customer service skills. He isn’t personable at all. He answers the phone “phone number” That’s it . Perhaps I only have a question, maybe I’m old and that’s how the younger crowd talk to others now ??
… more
lee briggs
We’ve been ordering from this place for years. At first, it was fantastic. The last 3 times, including tonight, it’s less than impressive. The pizza dough has been tasting very bland, and the sauce as well. Now, it looks, and tastes, like a “take n bake” pizza from a grocery store. The wings always taste like old oil lately too, and when you go in there, that smell sticks in your clothes. They’re even messing up orders lately. The last time, the pizza was sloppy, like soup in a box. This time, they sent the wrong wings, and cooked them wrong. ( not the way I asked for them, which was mild and crispy) and I received bbq and soggy. They’re charging homemade prices, for frozen quality. If you’re a family of 4, and thinking of ordering pizza, spend your $60 elsewhere
… more
Susan Price
The pizza itself is pretty good, not amazing but good. The wings is where we had problems. First, they weren’t crispy in any way. I could get over that, No problem, but then I realized my wings had feathers. Not just a stray chicken hair, full on feathers. When I called to complain, the owner got on and told me that this is how that are, that they do not check their wings before cooking them, they also don’t slaughter and pluck their own chickens so they had no control over what went out the door. When I said that was ridiculous, he hung up on me. When I called back I spoke to another man who said that the best they could do was have ME bring them the wings and as long as we hadn’t eaten any then they could refund me half the cost of the wings. When I explained that actual wings were on the bottom of the container the second man responded I know that happens but I need the wings back. This is ridiculous. I get that sometimes things happen and to be honest a simple I’m sorry would have gone a LONG LONG way, but they didn’t do anything but insult me.
… more
Frazr58
Pizza is mediocre but is priced good. Plus if you eat ten, you get a free one. The wings are a little different. I didn’t find any feathers but they look like the chickens were raised by a nuke plant. Big knuckles, deformities, etc. They are pretty good wings with a unique sauce but from time to time there are some strange pieces. Plus everything but the pizza is pricey for the amount of food you get. Make sure you dial the right number. It sucks when you call the wrong one and find your pizza is waiting for you on the other side of Clifton Park.
… more
Rick
Got the lunch special. Two cheese slices and a can soda for $5. Reasonable price. Pizza was good, crispy and had a nice sauce that tasted homemade. I’d return if in the area but I wouldn’t say it was amazing enough to go out of my way for.
… more
Jonathan Maglosky
Have ordered here more often than i’d like to admit, always great pizza, have never missed
… more
Lori Winters
Never ordered my right order but I’m ok. The pizza was right last nite. You make a delicious veggie pizza! Understand you’ve been very busy. Good for you! Thank you!
… more
… View more